Posted 2008-04-20 9:37 AM (#82302) Subject: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 368
Location: Georgia
Hello Everyone,
I am in need of a new trail saddle. I like the Tucker saddles. I am planning on using their measuring instructions for the horse and sending in and finding out which type would be best for my horse. Does anyone ride in a Tucker? Any comments both good and bad will be appreciated. I have been riding in a great old handmade Circle Y roping saddle but the weight has become an issue for me. It weighs almost 50lbs. Would like a GOOD lighter weight saddle.
Posted 2008-04-20 10:01 AM (#82303 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 2615
Tucker makes a very nice trail saddle.We have 2 of them,and their gel seat is excellent.However if you have a horse that has a different type of conformation other than what is pretty much standard,the saddle may not fit.My filly was fitted for a "medium" tree Tucker several years ago.As she developed,she had NO withers,and I had to go to a different saddle because the Tucker would not stay on.Tucker now owns Circle Y ,I believe.
Posted 2008-04-20 10:53 AM (#82308 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 479
Location: central sierra nevada foothills
I have had my Tucker for 14 years, and bought it directly from Tucker when they were a "mom and pop shop". I love mine, I have used it from trail riding to roping, and yes it held up pulling a 400 lb. calf out of the pond, he got stuck and had to rope and drag him out by dallying aroung the Tucker horn. I love mine, I have the wide tree and has fit every horse I have put it on. I also have severe arthritis and I am never as sore as I used to be in a regular saddle vs. my Tucker!
Posted 2008-04-20 1:47 PM (#82314 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Elite Veteran
Posts: 1069
Location: MI.
I own two High Plains and I love them. They're very comfortable. I have arabs and the wide tree Tucker fits them very well. I believe Tucker was the "original" gaited saddle. I could be wrong.....Anyhoo, it's a great saddle.
Posted 2008-04-20 1:48 PM (#82315 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 2453
Location: Northern Utah
I personally don't have a tucker, But several of my friends do and they really like their saddles. Both the older hard seats and newer Gel seats. If you like the feel and looks, I wouldn't worry too much about the Tuckers holding up. They seem to be well made and work well with the gaited horses my friends ride.
If you are worried about horses changing their conformation, I do have a Specialized Saddle that I use on Endurance rides and my daguhter like to use, because it's only 20+ pounds. Much lighter than my other western saddles. It is also a western looking saddle with a horn. It is very adjustable for different horses. You can shim the pads for different widths of horses. I wouldn't use it as a roping saddle, but it has held up for 10 years of endurance and trail riding. I've even on occassions thrown a panier over it and packed with it. http://www.specializedsaddles.com/new/
Posted 2008-04-20 6:07 PM (#82319 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 1416
Location: sc
I ride a Tucker High Plains. Fits both our horses well, very nice saddle.......but its probably the most uncomfortable saddle Ive ever sat in. I heard nothing but good things about Tucker so when the time came I ponied up the cash and bought a brand new one. Felt great....for the first hour. After that I guess my butt bone sank into all the padding and gel seat causing an uncomfortable leather "wedge" into the family jewels. Im 5'9" 175#, if that matters. Kept ridding it trying to break it in, not going to happen. Ended up wedging a basketball in between the saddle rack and the seat to break it down, after 2 weeks that worked. Rides good now, but man what an ordeal. Thought maybe it was a fluke until my wife demoed the Endurance model from Valley Vet, exact same complaint about 2 hours into the ride. Shes 5'3" 130#, if that matters. If I were you, try to demo one to see what you think before shelling out the cash. Comfort is of course a subjective thing, but Ive since talked to a few people with complaints similar to ours.
Posted 2008-04-20 7:36 PM (#82320 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA
At the last Equine Affaire, my wife bought the Tucker "Equestrian" for the purpose of trail riding. It weighs about 28 lbs and fits the horses and my wife quite well. With the longest ride to date, of about an hour and a half, she hasn't had any unpleasant issues.
She looked at and sat on many saddles at the Affaire. She went there knowing that the Tucker was one of two that had the form she wanted for trail riding; no horn, English styling, low pommel and a light weight. She found the quality and comfort to her liking and is looking forward to a week's riding in northern CA in May.
So far it has proven to be a very good saddle for her needs.
Posted 2008-04-21 10:48 AM (#82363 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 326
Location: Gallatin, TN
The fee for the demo saddle is money well spent when you consider the price of a Tucker. The best way to determine if this is the saddle for you, IMO, is to ride it. A friend of mine bought a Tucker and he loves it... but then he rode my Big Horn and couldn't see any difference in the comfort of the saddle or the fit on his horse. He did, however, see a big difference in the price!
Posted 2008-04-21 10:54 AM (#82364 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 479
Location: central sierra nevada foothills
I would love to get another one, but yeah, they are pricey. I found the receipt for mine and back then it was only $750! and that included shipping! Hard to find used ones, especially with the wide tree and small seat size I want....
Talking Tuckers, here is an article they did on me and my Tucker awhile back, kinda a human interest story.....hope the link still works.........
Posted 2008-04-21 11:07 AM (#82366 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 368
Location: Georgia
Thank you ALL for your replies. I most surely will use the demo service. I have a fairly sizable western store near my home that is a Tucker dealer. Before I request a demo saddle, I am going to go and sit in one at the store for a while. I know that won't be the same as riding in one but at least maybe I can be sure I want to do the demo service. If the saddle feels pretty good at the store (gonna take my horse too and set one on his back) then it will be demo ordering time. I really appreciate the time you all took to reply to my request for comments. It was very helpful.
Posted 2008-04-21 11:19 AM (#82370 - in reply to #82362) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA
Originally written by cowpony01 on 2008-04-21 11:44 AM
Gard,
Where's your wife going in No. Cali.? I am in the central sierra nevada foothills of Cali. would be fun to campfire with yall!
Thank you for the offer. My wife's riding will be based out of the Cowboy Hiding Ranch in the Blue Lakes area north of Frisco. She will be going to the Highland Springs reservoir, Ridgewood Ranch (Seabiscuit) The Mendocino Coast and the Upper Lake areas. Some off hours will be spent savoring the local vineyards. With only a week and a half time period, she is somewhat limited on the scope of her travels.
I hope your campfires are plentiful and enjoyable. Thanks again.
Posted 2008-04-21 11:22 AM (#82372 - in reply to #82370) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 479
Location: central sierra nevada foothills
sounds like she is gonna be around the bay areas, and northern bay areas then, the mountains on the other side of my mountains. Is she going for vacation and are you joining her? If ya'd both like to see the sierras someday, give me a hollar, can take you on the trails that the pioneers came on and crossed the sierras on.......
Posted 2008-04-21 11:30 AM (#82374 - in reply to #82372) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA
Originally written by cowpony01 on 2008-04-21 12:22 PM
sounds like she is gonna be around the bay areas, and northern bay areas then, the mountains on the other side of my mountains. Is she going for vacation and are you joining her? If ya'd both like to see the sierras someday, give me a hollar, can take you on the trails that the pioneers came on and crossed the sierras on.......
That sounds like the offer of a lifetime! My wife and her friend will be vacationing together. I am unable to ride for any length of time, and would drastically hinder her enjoyment. This is her third trip to CA, maybe the next one will be in your area. Thank you again
Posted 2008-04-21 8:31 PM (#82395 - in reply to #82366) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 434
Location: Brooksville, Fl
I demo'ed a Tucker saddle a few years ago and it wasn't my cup of tea and didn't fit my horse well. I would recommend using all of the time you can get while you have the demo. I rode for about 10 hours total in the week that I had mine. It was the best money I've ever spent when saddle shopping. I ended up with a Bob Marshall Sport saddle and I've never looked back. I demo'ed that as well and chose to keep it.
I'm not saying the Tucker is bad but, if you can demo ANY saddle, ride in it as much as you can. You can't always tell how things will work out in a 1 hour ride. Just like any saddle, some will fit, some won't and some you will like and some you won't.
Posted 2008-04-22 8:17 AM (#82405 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Expert
Posts: 1205
Location: Arkansas
Have a Circle Y Durango, (slick fork)with an Old Timer flex tree. the vet's wife rode it and sold her Tucker and got one. Farrier's friend 's wife has a Tucker, and liked that particlular Circle Y better, much to her dismay as her husband was not happy about that. I think Tucker makes good products, so , to do as above and ride a demo to the max, that is how to figure if they could make one perfect for you. I think, quality being equal, it is a matter of equine fit, human fit, and of course style and $ as preferred. I also know people who are very well satisfied with the Tucker's they have. What I mean is not to be detracting from the Tuckers, just that sometimes people's riding style or personal fit preference is what makes the difference..try all you can!
Posted 2008-04-24 7:23 AM (#82541 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Elite Veteran
Posts: 1069
Location: MI.
It may also depend on the Tucker model. Try a few different ones and go from there. There are alot of nice, well fitting comfortable saddles out there aside from Tucker.
Posted 2008-04-24 1:35 PM (#82566 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 368
Location: Georgia
Took my horse to the local western store last night. Tried several trail saddles on his back. None of the Big Horn saddles tried fit him very well. One of the new Tucker Gen IIs fit well. The old style Tuckers (not Gen II) did not fit. I have to be careful of the skirt size in addition to the withers because a 26 inch skirt is too long. I got a new Trail Rider magazine today with lots of advertisements for trail saddles. I am going to look into some of those as well. The owner of my local western store was gracious enough to order two different New Tucker GenII styles for me to try with no obligation from me other than a $50.00 deposit. She said she could always sell the saddles to someone else. I was pleased with her efforts to help me in my hunt for a good trail saddle. I will keep my progress posted.
Thanks again for all of your replies.
Posted 2008-04-25 8:31 AM (#82585 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Member
Posts: 9
Location: Melder, La.
I have the Tucker Plantation and have ridden it for 8 yrs. now. I love it, it fits my horse well, and is really comfortable. I ride Paso's and need the round skirt as they are short coupled. Also, I hate a horn, so it works for me.
Posted 2008-04-25 12:50 PM (#82615 - in reply to #82594) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Elite Veteran
Posts: 781
Location: La Cygne, KS
For those that want to look at other saddle brands, I have been extremely pleased with my RL Watson saddle. It has flex panels so it will fit a variety of horses and the workmanship is awesome.
I have the continental - flatter seat/less rise and it is the most comfortable saddle I have ever ridden it. And because the panels flex, if fits my slightly sway backed 27 year-old Arab, to my broad QH - to my mutton withered, narrow Foxtrotter. And I have ridden in it over 150 miles since I got it last fall with no soreness to the horses back or mine.
Posted 2008-05-03 9:11 PM (#83069 - in reply to #82395) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Veteran
Posts: 140
Location: Ft. Lawn, South Carolina
Ditto on the Bob Marshall saddle!!! I looked for what seemed like forever, demo rode a few and some of my friends as well.....rode that BMSS and I was hooked. They are also pricey, but well worth the money. Happy trails!
Posted 2008-05-07 8:50 AM (#83357 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Regular
Posts: 85
I had a Tucker High Plains and got rid of it. Did not like the way it made me sit and it constantly listed to one side on any horse I put it on. I had to get a round skirt model as the skirt was too long for my short backed horse. I did like the Montreal breast collar though!
Posted 2008-05-07 11:07 AM (#83380 - in reply to #82302) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 479
Location: central sierra nevada foothills
WoW! Ust reading some of the comments on how Tuckers have had some issues with others, Tucker has changed drastically over the years, as my saddle has fit every horse I have put it on and broke alot of mares with it. But prob. because Tucker sold out to is it "circle Y", can't remember who they sold to. Like I said, I got mine when they were just a mom and pop shop way back, shows ya how saddles change when another company takes over.......
Posted 2008-05-07 11:45 AM (#83385 - in reply to #83380) Subject: RE: Tucker saddles
Elite Veteran
Posts: 781
Location: La Cygne, KS
Tucker bought Circle Y. Was at a saddle fitting demo a few weeks ago with a friend and talked to a Tucker rep. He said the older Tucker saddles were constructed better because they were individually made, not a production line like they are now.
The Generation II saddles look better in leather quality, but saw that some of the screw heads on the pommel area were crooked. However, if a saddle fits the horse and you and is within your budget then it is a good purchase whether new or used.