'
1
Forums Albums Skins 1
Search Register Logon


You are logged in as a guest. Logon or register an account to access more features.
OTHER FORUMS:    Barrel Horses  -   Trucks   -   Cutting  -   Reining  -   Roping 
'
4500 chevy

Jump to page : 1 2
Now viewing page 1 [25 messages per page]
Last activity 2006-06-23 12:12 AM
35 replies, 5982 views

View previous thread :: View next thread
   General Discussion -> Trailer Talk  Click to return to Barrel Talk
Refresh
Message format
 
hav2ride
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-17 9:21 AM (#43136)
Subject: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 1719
1000500100100
Location: PA
About a year or so ago, someone on this board bought a 4500. If you are still on this board, could you e-mail me about your truck? Or anyone who has experience with these trucks tell me what you love and hate about them. Thanks.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
3yrHitch2Bumper
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-17 1:22 PM (#43160 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Regular


Posts: 98
252525
Location: Midwest USA

 

Some people might not like what I am about to say,but here it goes......

A couple years ago when these trucks came out,they were the greatest thing going....alittle bigger than a 3500...more braking power...crew cab...companies doing nice conversions...$65-$75,000 list prices...dvd...air seats...hauler bed...leather trim.. etc..etc..etc... it was a great idea by GM to put these trucks out...but since then the market has not been good to them.....as of today....trade in values are very low.....they are not holding there value.....I have dealt with people who have traded their C4500 in with less than 10,000 miles & are taking $15,000/$20,000 hits.....This is true....NO BS.....to be very frank....the truck is nothing more than a over sized dually.....Your dealers are making alot of $$ on the consumer....but the consumer is not getting it back on the back end......It is true....

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
MrTruck
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-17 2:18 PM (#43167 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Elite Veteran


Posts: 1160
10001002525
Location: Denver Colorado

hav2ride already has my opinion of the C4500. Monroe sent me one last summer and I towed several trailers with it. The big test was to see how the Monroe bed would fit under horse trailers. The tailgate was around 58" for the 2 wheel drive which is lower than a 4 x 4 Ford F150 04 and newer. It fit under the 8 or 9 horse trailers fine with 8" or more bed rail room. My only negative experience was the ride was rougher than a GM 3500. Like all wide trucks, M2, International, Pete etc. they have a wide front end so the shoulder of dirt roads can be spooky.

But the C4500's frame is 80k psi about 3 times more than a 3500, more fuel tank options, more axle ration options, (2500/3500 only have the 3.73 axle with the Duramax). C4500 has 15" disc brakes all around, I think the 3500 is 12". Tip forward cab with swing out components, this also gives you great visibility. The C4500 can have factory air seat, air cab, and rear air suspension, the 3500 not.

C4500 will turn dramatically tighter than a 3500, I drove this one thru bank drive-ups, McDonalds drive-thru's, parked it at Walmart, drove it everywhere and used the air horn alot. The cab is gigantic since it is a full size van cab, this gives you a dog-house to get to the back of the engine, large windows, tall enough ceiling to almost stand up in. The rear seat is larger than Dodge Mega-cab and you can look out the rear picture window and see the gooseneck ball.

It's diesel power is rated lower than a Duramax in the 2500/3500 because as with most medium trucks it's designed to be loaded 90% of the time not 10%. But with the lower axles, you still have excellent towing ability. The C4500 comes with a factory standard exhaust brake. Now for tow ratings it's about equal to the 3500 because of CDL 26,000 GVW laws. It should be rated to tow 10,000#'s more than a 3500 and have argued with GM on that point. We might see that in 2008 (January) I could go on an on, but I suppose to be writing an article about the 2005-6-07-08 C4500/5500.

And that's my story and I'm stickin to it.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hav2ride
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-17 2:19 PM (#43168 - in reply to #43160)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 1719
1000500100100
Location: PA
Brad, I know they aren't M2s but I want to hear from people who actually use them.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Reg
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-18 6:40 AM (#43189 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 2689
2000500100252525
I doubt that they depreciate (as a percentage of PAID price over time) any faster than M2s {which are in the 6 figure bracket}
(-:

New vehicles are SO heavily discounted these days that it no longer makes sense to compare resale to MSRP
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Tx. Vaquero
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-18 6:25 PM (#43205 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy




100100100100
Location: Texas
First let me preface this by saying I haul about 50,000 miles/yr. chasing that elusive $100 belt buckle, so that tells you how smart I am. I own a late 2004-4500 with LLy Duramax. The truck has 118,000 miles on it pulling mainly a heavy 34' horse trailer. I have had no trouble with the truck. I paid $48,000 for it new with Monroe hauler bed, airride and leather seats. I have since added Edge and aux. fuel tank. I haul with two buddies, one has an FL60 and the other a new Sportchassis. I previously had an older FL60. I can certainly haul with these guys, and for the money, I won't be going back. A new guy to our bunch just got a new IH and it is really an impressive truck. I'm just a cowboy, not a truck salesman.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hav2ride
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-19 8:29 AM (#43235 - in reply to #43205)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 1719
1000500100100
Location: PA
Do you know what your trailer weighs? What did it haul like without the edge juice? Do you ever chase those buckles thru the mountains? If so, how does it pull them and what rear end ratio does the truck have? I almost asked you what rear end YOU have! LOL!!
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Tx. Vaquero
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-19 10:49 AM (#43248 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy




100100100100
Location: Texas
My trailer weighs 12,800 empty, usually around 17,500 loaded with horses, feed, water, fuel, etc. The truck weighs 10,800 empty, about 12,000 loaded. I have hauled through the Rockies several times, Colorado, Wyoming, Montana, and the truck handled it as well as you could expect. Could run in 5th gear most of the time. I let transmission temp. and EGT dictate how hard I push. The Edge made a significant difference in pulling power as well as mileage. The truck has a 4.44 rear end. Mine is lower.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
PaintPony
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2006-06-19 11:56 AM (#43254 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Veteran


Posts: 115
100

I may be the one you're referring to. I bought one last year and I LOVE it!

Anyone who thinks it's just an "overgrown" dually has never driven one very much. The handling and, most importantly, the BRAKING  is soooo far over that of a dually. Having the exhaust brake option I find myself hardly using the regular brakes. These trucks do ride a bit rougher than a pickup but HEY they're NOT pickups! I've driven mine in and around New Orleans where the roads are absolutely terrible and I've made 2 trips in it from NC to LA. Once with a trailer, once empty. Nope, not like a Sunday drive in Pa's lincoln but certainly not bad enough to be unhappy with the truck. I have very little experience pulling trailers in the mountains but took a trip up last month and actually enjoyed the drive. Being able to just let off the pedal and have instant "braking" is awesome. In the past pulling a trailer down grades has left me feeling a little out of control but with this truck there is no question. I can't describe the feeling of security you have when stepping up to a medium duty truck when pulling.

That said these trucks aren't without their issues. The best place to learn more about them is the chevy medium duty diesel forum - http://www.dieselplace.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=34 however take what some of these guys say with a grain of salt. I think many of them are expecting too much out of these trucks. If you intend to work it every day then maybe you'd be better off spending quite a bit more to step up to a international or freightliner. I found some of their posts a little scary and spent the first month or two waiting for problems. I've put quite a few miles on her now (and it had 15K on it when I bought it) and have yet to be disappointed. My dealer has also been really good about fixing the small issues that I have had.

My rig weighs in at almost 19K completely empty. We run 26000 lb farm tags on it. There is some discussion (to which no one seems to have a clear answer) as to what type of tags/lic you need in order to be legal. In addition to my horse trailer we also pull a big flatbed farm trailer with tractors and other equipment. I'd be happy to talk in more detail via email if desired. tfarmer @ esn.net.

Here's a pic of my rig sitting on the scales. I know, the trailer's tiny compared to what a lot of you guys pull. I shudder now whenever I see a really big trailer hooked to a Dually! Did I mention that I LOVE my truck? LOL!



Edited by PaintPony 2006-06-19 12:29 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Truck Broker
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2006-06-20 9:23 AM (#43316 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Veteran


Posts: 104
100
Location: Missouri
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hounddog
Reg. Dec 2005
Posted 2006-06-20 9:27 AM (#43318 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 1205
1000100100
Location: Danielsville Georgia
Ay other engine option besides the D/max ?
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Truck Broker
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2006-06-20 9:46 AM (#43322 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Veteran


Posts: 104
100
Location: Missouri
Well, I guess I'll be the devil's advocate here. I bought one brand new in 03'. Reg cab, 11' hauler bed, 300hp Dmax, Allison auto, 4.44 rear axle ratio. I was using it to pull a 6-horse trailer with an 8' shortwall weekend LQ that was 8' wide and 7'6" high. I absolutely hated this truck. Wouldn't own another one if you gave it to me. Pulling my 6-horse trailer even empty the truck just as well have not had a 5th gear because on flat ground it wouldn't pull 5th, on all hills it was in 4th and much of the time 3rd gear and screaming down the road getting 6-7 mpg doing it. One trip from central Missouri to Minnisota(flat ground) with only 2 horses in the trailer we were stoping every 180-200 miles to refuel, and were having a hard time maintaining 55-60 mph. Some guys say, "add a chip, that'll fix your problem". I don't believe in that. If the factory wanted the truck to be programed fro that much power, they'd have made it that way. Chips make these things run hotter and wear out sooner, and the Duramax engine is no big truck engine like a Cummins, or a Cat, or International, like most of the other medium duty's are running. In my opinion the truck it self is a mediocre medium duty. AS others mentioned the wide front axle can make them handle real funny on some roads, and I am not talking about funny haha but have to stop and change you pants funny. The main deturent for me is the drivetrain, the Duramax is not a good medium duty truck engine in my opinion, great for pick-ups, but not for medium duty's. It doesn't have the low end grunt that a big Dt466, 7.2 Cat, or C series Cummins has, it will be winded and shot long before the others. Just because you put a light duty pick-up engine in a medium duty truck doesn't make it a medium duty engine.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hounddog
Reg. Dec 2005
Posted 2006-06-20 10:59 AM (#43327 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 1205
1000100100
Location: Danielsville Georgia
That was the reason I asked if any other engines available.Oh well.

Edited by hounddog 2006-06-20 11:00 AM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
MrTruck
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-20 11:28 AM (#43328 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Elite Veteran


Posts: 1160
10001002525
Location: Denver Colorado

Just like in a Ford F450/550, the C4500/5500 only one diesel option. And that is the comparison. C4500 is a class 4 truck just like a Ford F450. So it's not a fair comparison to put these 1 1/2 ton trucks in the class with Freightliner M2, Ford 650, Pete 330 and International 4300/4700 all class 6 trucks and above. These semi-truck manufactures take their over the road trucks, lower the classification on the springs and offer hydraulic brakes and make them hauler trucks. This is where the momentum is growing, folks are getting larger trailers, so all the truck manufactures are looking to sell there. Also be aware of what the excise tax (12% like an over the road tax) is. The IRS raised the weight limit and clarrified that last year.

I know the C4500 is a tall truck, so we tend to compare it with semi-trucks. Compare it to F450's and the new HD 3500 C&C Dodge coming this fall. Ford owned this market for so long with GM coming late and Dodge coming later. I dream of M2's too. And if I towed heavy trailers all the time, I'm sure I'd have one. I'm thinking of getting a 3/4 ton now and might even get a gas engine as much as I love diesels. But it's an ecomonic decision not emotional. Yeah right.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
brushycreekranch
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-20 9:18 PM (#43361 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy





500100100100100
Location: Central Arkansas

Mr Truck....you may take my M2 for a test drive if you are ever in my area.

They finally came out with the Steer Safe for the M2 so no more of that abrupt grab the shoulder and go. I had it on my 02 FL 60 Sportchassis and could not believe it could take so long to become available for the M2. It is the greatest gadget since the microwave. Now we just float across the bumps and potholes. I recommend the Steer Safe for any medium duty hauler or motorhome. I think it was about $695 installed.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
MrTruck
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-20 10:08 PM (#43364 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Elite Veteran


Posts: 1160
10001002525
Location: Denver Colorado
It's not that far to Colorado, bring it by and I'll break it in right. Need to see if it's mountain worthy. I'll know in a couple of months.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
brushycreekranch
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-21 8:19 AM (#43373 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy





500100100100100
Location: Central Arkansas
Mr Truck...You're too funny! But I know it is mountain worthy. We took it out to CO & WY last year and my 20 year old son ( who drives large ambulances and fire trucks for a living) drove it  up and over Monarch pass........with no trailer brakes. Our 4H LQ trailer has electric over hydraulic brakes but Sportchassis had installed a Prodigy brake control. So the read out on the box showed a connection but the brakes were in fact inactive. It didn't matter though since the truck was more than capable  and he rarely even had use the truck brakes since the truck engine and tranny did almost all of the work. In fact, we didn't even know the brake controller was not talking to the trailer brakes until AFTER the trip when the rig went in for service.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
3yrHitch2Bumper
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-21 10:14 AM (#43383 - in reply to #43373)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Regular


Posts: 98
252525
Location: Midwest USA
VERY NICE STORY !!!  
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
3yrHitch2Bumper
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-21 10:17 AM (#43384 - in reply to #43364)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Regular


Posts: 98
252525
Location: Midwest USA

MR TRUCK......WHY HAVE YOU NOT DONE A REVIEW ON THE HOTTEST & FASTEST SELLING HAULER TRUCK ON THE MARKET YET???***** M2 SPORT CHASSIS ******  I KNOW THE BOYS OUT THERE IN CLINTON,OK WOULD WELCOME YOU WITH OPEN ARMS...JUST WONDERING.....

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
MrTruck
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-21 10:25 AM (#43385 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Elite Veteran


Posts: 1160
10001002525
Location: Denver Colorado
I am planning on reviewing an M2 this summer. It's going to be a busy year. Alot of truck changes.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Tx. Vaquero
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-21 6:26 PM (#43416 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy




100100100100
Location: Texas
I just got to civilization, Casper, and decided to look in on this deal. I guess I am a naive rookie that thought when someone asked a question, they were looking for candid input, not self serving BS from a bunch of hungry sharks trying to pimp their product. Anyway, I stand by what I said. If this truck gets winded and lays down tommorow, it doesn' owe me anything, and I still have most of the $80,000 I saved. The guy with the new SportsChassis is still with me. The others went home. I didn't say they weren't really good trucks, because they are, just overpriced in my simple way of looking at things. We are off for Bozeman, then Boise, then Calgary.., then I forget but who cares. I haven't been passed by any micro-busses with Missouri plates loaded with out of work truck traders, but then I have managed to keep it above 55 while screaming downhill in third gear getting 5 MPG and having to stop every 150 miles, which is about how often we stop anyway for beer and to let the pony's breath. I am just a cowboy, not a truck salesman. I'm going to let the dog drive for awhile so I can read this and type.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Reg
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-21 9:15 PM (#43418 - in reply to #43416)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy


Expert


Posts: 2689
2000500100252525
Originally written by Tx. Vaquero on 2006-06-21 6:26 PM

I just got to civilization, Casper, and decided to look in on this deal. I guess I am a naive rookie that thought when someone asked a question, they were looking for candid input, not self serving BS from a bunch of hungry sharks trying to pimp their product. Anyway, I stand by what I said. If this truck gets winded and lays down tommorow, it doesn' owe me anything, and I still have most of the $80,000 I saved. The guy with the new SportsChassis is still with me. The others went home. I didn't say they weren't really good trucks, because they are, just overpriced in my simple way of looking at things. We are off for Bozeman, then Boise, then Calgary.., then I forget but who cares. I haven't been passed by any micro-busses with Missouri plates loaded with out of work truck traders, but then I have managed to keep it above 55 while screaming downhill in third gear getting 5 MPG and having to stop every 150 miles, which is about how often we stop anyway for beer and to let the pony's breath. I am just a cowboy, not a truck salesman. I'm going to let the dog drive for awhile so I can read this and type.



You noticed that too, eh ?

Nothing like redistributing manufacturers' ad copy and labelling it as "experience" or "opinion" (-:

Edited by Reg 2006-06-21 9:18 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Tx. Vaquero
Reg. Jun 2006
Posted 2006-06-21 9:52 PM (#43419 - in reply to #43418)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy




100100100100
Location: Texas
hey Reg- yeah I'm a little slow but finally picked up on it. I have been checking things out on this site for a while, since a buddy reffered me as a good place to get info. This is the first time I have responded to anything, but since I am living with one of these trucks I bought with my own hard earned money and depend on to get me around, I thought I'd share my experience. I'm sure smart enough to know what I don't know, and I've picked up some good tips here, like your deal on fuel filters, and others. Guess I just stepped off into the wrong deal. Oh well, what the hell. It breaks up the monotony during slack.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
HWBar
Reg. Nov 2005
Posted 2006-06-22 5:33 AM (#43425 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Expert


Posts: 1283
1000100100252525
Location: Home of Wild Turkey Whiskey
I'm glad Reg and Tx. Vaquero see what I see, A snake lieing in the grass trying to sell his product on a forum. Even using product talking points verbatim. I bet the snake is a known advertiser to the monitors. Now that two other posters are calling him out it will be interesting to see if they leave the post up.

Edited by HWBar 2006-06-22 5:46 AM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
MrTruck
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-06-22 12:02 PM (#43452 - in reply to #43136)
Subject: RE: 4500 chevy



Elite Veteran


Posts: 1160
10001002525
Location: Denver Colorado

Guys, what are you talking about. I'm a moderator here and have read the posts several times on this thread looking for what you are talking about and don't see it. I don't know why the witch hunt for dealers. Did you buy your truck and trailer directly from the manufacture? Did you buy your horse from it's mother? In this thread I don't see a vilian. I know a few hundred truck and horse trailer dealers and the majority of the ones in the business for a while are a wealth of  trailer information. They deal daily with the issues we talk about here. Of course you have to be wise when buying and negotating, no different then following along in the Bible so your preacher doesn't sneek in his slant on things Sunday morning.

I do appreciate dealers that identify themselves when posting. But I also want their imput on questions. We don't have folks here pass a test before they give advice. So as on any forum, advice needs filtered by your own common since and research. I don't have time to be in every post and don't know how anyone could spend all day every day. If you want to debate this in private, send me a PM.

Thanks for sharing your story Tx. Vaquero. Folks with direct experience with the topic are what folks are looking for with their questions and with the size of this forum, we should have experience with just about every trailer/truck question. 

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Jump to page : 1 2
Now viewing page 1 [25 messages per page]
Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread
Message format
 

'
Registered to: Horse Trailer World
(Delete all cookies set by this site)