Posted 2007-01-15 10:15 PM (#53912) Subject: Barefoot Performance: Barrel Racing - our story
Member
Posts: 36 Location: Greasewood Springs, AZ
Last April, I noticed our AQHA mare High Flying Princess' front left hoof had a pretty bad crack. I started monitoring it and she was barrel racing every weekend and it only got worse. I tried Horseshoer's Secret to no avail ( We did switch to Formula 707 Biostride and it is fantastic!). I consulted our farrier and he recommended a hotshoe. I deferred to his judgement and let him hotshoe Princess. About two weeks, mid May, and one race after she was hotshoed she came up lame. I quickly pulled the shoes and fought with the hoof that was hotshoed. She was in so much pain and it just really hurt me to see her suffer. I thought to myself, I just need to really research the "why we shoe horses" when she runs in sand and dirt which is really non-intrusive. I started a crazy search on Google typing "shoeless horses" " no shoe horse" on and on and finally found http://www.thehorseshoof.com ... I was so happy because what my gut had been telling me someone had researched and given me the "authority" to proceed to go shoeless for the 2006 season.
But I was still not 100%...my wifes' father, a respected horsemen in the Navajo community, was not buying it, and convinced me to try another farrier. We drove 200 miles to Cortez and had Chance Tate shoe Princess...yes, everyone cringe! While he is a great farrier and has a wonderful T3 Stables, Princess threw a shoe on the first barrel and running on three shoes and 11 vertabrae out according to our chiropractor. I was angry! I was so angry with myself for not trusting what I felt for our horse. I vowed after causing her the additional pain because of my stupidity that she would not wear shoes again period!
During our 2006 rodeo season, Princess competed in both Pro and Indian rodeos. Her best finish in the pro circuit was 10th in Clovis, New Mexico. She also qualified for the INFR and won Triple JJJ Rodeo in Chinle, Whiteriver Rodeo, Northern Navajo Rodeo in Bluff, Central Navajo Fair in Chinle, Bylas Mt. Turnbull Rodeo, Western Navajo Fair Rodeo, SWIRA Champion Barrel Racer 2006 and was fourth in the average at the Navajo Nation Fair. Yes, all without horseshoes!
Why didn't she win the Indian National Finals Rodeo this year? Again, my self confidence and stupidity! I allowed our farrier to trim her before we raced the final two races! He trimmed her too close and I was against the trim but my wife's father went ahead with it anyway! Now I really need to either learn to trim or find someone to trim our horse!
I am currently under intense pressure from her father to have her shoed! Guess what? I just smile and say I respect your "old school thoughts" but how can you argue with six first place finishes? We want to be the only winning PWBR (PRCA) Barrel Racing shoeless horse on the Turquoise Circuit! We hope to preach the gospel of shoeless horses and have already won one convert...Claudia's best friend and Breakaway Roper Savannah Begay!
Posted 2007-01-15 11:17 PM (#53916 - in reply to #53912) Subject: RE: Barefoot Performance: Barrel Racing - our story
Regular
Posts: 91 Location: Small Town, Texas
Great news! My daughters horse has had terrible hooves since we had him for th past year. I think it was just from shoes being left on too long and neglect. I can not wait to get the last hoof out a litle longer and we are going to try and go barefoot. Our other three horses do and we have never had a problem. We mostly trail and pleasure ride nothing intense....I really think sometime every time we get a nail in the hoof it just does more damage....It is veryhard to get past using shoes and I keep thinking the next time they are shod I am going to have our farrier remove them....
Posted 2007-01-16 6:12 AM (#53922 - in reply to #53912) Subject: RE: Barefoot Performance: Barrel Racing - our story
Expert
Posts: 2453 Location: Northern Utah
I took my horses barefoot last year. Pulled the shoes at Thanksgiving as usually but didn't put them back on when spring came. I don't compete, I just trail ride and some pretty rocky places.
One gelding didn't do well barefoot at all. I suspect we trimmed him just a touch too long. He showed soreness after rides, so I put him back in shoes for the rest of the summer. We will try him again this summer and correct our trim.
The other horses surviced the summer. But I did notice they got tender if I rode them for 4-5 hours on rough trails. They slowed down their gaits, No more "Charging " down the trail. They would walk on the side of the trail as opposded to down the middle. Much more observant of where they put their feet. But no persistent soreness after they got off the trail.
I'm not sure I could have rode those horses for 2-3 days straight on rough trails. But given a day off, they did fine. A fellow I occassionally ride with, who is a vet and was a farrier earlier in his carreer has gone barefoot for the last 5 years. He horses do great with it.
For 2007 we hope to continue barefoot. We hope they have toughened up their feet and can go 5+ hours or multiple days with out showing any tenderness. My farrier and I have both learned a lot about how to properly trim a barefoot hoof. I alternate trims with my farrier. I do a trim at 4 weeks and the farrier comes and "Trues Up" my trim every 8 weeks.
My advice (for what it's worth with one years experience) is that some horses do fine, some don't. The proper trim is critcal. Just like if your fingernails get long they have a tendency to get dirt under the nails or to break off, the same is true for the hoof. keep them trim frequently and to correct shape. And yes it takes some time for horses that have been shod for a long time to convert over.
Riding on Red Mountain near Bryce Canyon
Rocky trails up deer & Elk hunting in October. Horse did great.
A November ride, almost 1 year since starting barefoot.
Posted 2007-01-16 8:24 PM (#53958 - in reply to #53927) Subject: RE: Barefoot Performance: Barrel Racing - our story
Expert
Posts: 2453 Location: Northern Utah
Pictures are quite as far south as you. But you probably rodeo'd by some of them.
So what kind of a difference are you seeing? Faster growth, stronger hoof walls. Tougher frogs?
I'm getting plenty of growth with no suppliments. In fact my problem is with keeping the hooves trimed back so I don't get any leverage on the white line. My horses get a little tender in the sole of the foot when traveling on pebble sized gravel. But I'm not seeing any chiping or excessive wear of the hoof wall. I'm hoping this second year barefoot will show some tougher feet.
Posted 2007-01-17 3:48 PM (#53992 - in reply to #53912) Subject: RE: Barefoot Performance: Barrel Racing - our story
Member
Posts: 36 Location: Greasewood Springs, AZ
Princess is a hard keeper - especially her hooves...they grow at a snails pace but are brittle and prone to crack or in one instance split up the center...hence the hotshoe.
Her hooves are more pliable not as dry and the cracks are healing with proper maintenance. Her hooves are growing in more rapidly. And all around they look better...I don't know how to say it but darker healthier hooves.
Posted 2007-01-17 10:38 PM (#54013 - in reply to #53912) Subject: RE: Barefoot Performance: Barrel Racing - our story
Expert
Posts: 2828 Location: Southern New Mexico
I had a paint horse with white feet that everyone kept telling me I needed shoes on. I had him for 5 years with no shoes and never a sore day. He would walk off to the side on really rocky trails but he never tripped or hesitated. The lady I sold him to put shoes on him and right away he started having foot problems. She ended up having to keep him barefoot, she said he walked so slow and had to jog to catch up and that she thought she was "helping him out" by shoeing him. He was slow, the same way any 14 hand horse would be slow while walking next to a 17 hand horse. In my opinion sometimes people "help" to much.