Posted 2010-12-20 11:16 AM (#128205) Subject: minimum truck use?
Regular
Posts: 95 Location: Seattle "pshaw, its not raining hardly at all!" WA
ok, another newbie question.
I have my truck. new to me, 1996 Dodge Ram 3500 cummins diesel dually. 160K miles. did I mention the pony mudflaps? heh.
anyway.
how often do I need to drive this thing ot keep it healthy over the winter? I have my wee car for commuting, etc and frankly, this truck wont fit into the parking garage at work (ah, urban life...) so since we're not hauling over the winter, it sits in my driveway waiting for a job.
I know trucks and cars (like horses!) are really happiest when they get USED. is a once a week 12 mile trip to the barn and back enough to keep my new red truck healthy and happy? I keep trying to find friends who need plywood picked up at the lumber yard, or who need help moving but again, its winter in the NorthWet and everyone is pretty much holed up for the next couple months...
Posted 2010-12-20 12:09 PM (#128206 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Location: Colorado
Is it 12 miles one way? If so, I'd think that would work. One of the things is when you drive it, it's best if you run it long enough to let it get up to operating temperature. Especially a diesel engine. 12 miles is anywhere from 15 to 30 minutes, and that should work OK I would think.
Posted 2010-12-20 2:13 PM (#128211 - in reply to #128206) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 2453 Location: Northern Utah
That kind of a drive would also help to top off the battery. Modern trucks have parasitc electrical draw for the various components. Clock in dash, Electronic Odometer, maintaining your preset radio stations etc. so depending on what electronics are installed in your truck, there will always be some draw on the battery unless you unhook it. Instead of unhooking it, Just drive the truck once or twice a week and it will chagge the battery enough to keep it topped off.
Posted 2010-12-20 2:43 PM (#128213 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 5870 Location: western PA
It's important that the truck is actually driven and that the engine temperature is brought to its normal opperating temperature and maintained. Short trips or starting the motor and allowing it to idle for a limited while, will do more harm than good.
A diesel will not quickly come up its normal temperatures while it is idling from cold. A slow idle on a diesel will also wash the cylinder walls with excess fuel, cutting its lubrication. Everytime the engine is cold started, over a quart of water is dumped into the crankcase. Over time and high temperatures, this normally evaporates. When it cannot, the oil is water diluted, any metal above the top surface of the oil is exposed to rust, the exhaust system will rust from the inside out etc. Look at the tailpipe of any engine that is started on a cold day. You will see actual water dripping from the opening. Several of our posters have experienced their oil pans rusting from the inside out. Water is the cause and it's expensive to repair.
It would be better to have the truck sit unused with a battery tender maintaining the batteries, rather than multiple cold starts polluting the engine with water.
Posted 2010-12-20 4:46 PM (#128216 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 1351 Location: Decatur, Texas
Originally written by ornerie on 2010-12-20 11:16 AM
ok, another newbie question.
I have my truck. new to me, 1996 Dodge Ram 3500 cummins diesel dually. 160K miles. did I mention the pony mudflaps? heh.
anyway.
how often do I need to drive this thing ot keep it healthy over the winter? I have my wee car for commuting, etc and frankly, this truck wont fit into the parking garage at work (ah, urban life...) so since we're not hauling over the winter, it sits in my driveway waiting for a job.
I know trucks and cars (like horses!) are really happiest when they get USED. is a once a week 12 mile trip to the barn and back enough to keep my new red truck healthy and happy? I keep trying to find friends who need plywood picked up at the lumber yard, or who need help moving but again, its winter in the NorthWet and everyone is pretty much holed up for the next couple months...
or am I worrying needlessly?
Yes, drive it and while at the barn leave it running if possible. It is better on these trucks to let the idle instead of starting and stopping them all the time. How many big trucks at the local truck stops you see running? nearly all of them and most will have the same type engine and are left running for a reason. (ever priced a starter?) Mine is the newer 6.7L and when it is started in the morning I do not turn it off unless I absolutely have too.
Posted 2010-12-20 7:18 PM (#128223 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 420 Location: Florida
My F350 is driven less than three miles every few weeks in the deep winter starting about now just to dump the manure and get hay and grain.
Occasionally my wife will take it to work or we run an errand.
I have the original batteries 2005. I have used this item for 3 winters now. It remains plugged in 24 x7 it is mounted under my hood, she spins over like a top.
Posted 2010-12-20 8:44 PM (#128225 - in reply to #128213) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Regular
Posts: 92 Location: Harrisburg, PA
Everytime the engine is cold started, over a quart of water is dumped into the crankcase.
I'd like to know the source of this statistic. I've never seen even a tablespoon of water in oil when I change, and I have been known to move the car/truck into the garage, cut the engine and drain it.
To the OP, the common wisdom I've heard is that it helps to run the vehicle regularly (once every week or two) enough to let it warm up well. I think 20 min will do it for most trucks. It also helps to change the oil before the storage period (winter).
Posted 2010-12-20 11:20 PM (#128231 - in reply to #128225) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 5870 Location: western PA
Originally written by dgeesaman on 2010-12-20 9:44 PM
Everytime the engine is cold started, over a quart of water is dumped into the crankcase.
I'd like to know the source of this statistic.
When I worked for the airlines, every year we had to be recertified for pushbacks, using tugs to move the aircraft. They were powered by Detroit Diesel motors. Pit weather often drops to zero, and when the tugs are shut of for 45 - 60 mins at a time, they rappidly cool down. Then they are fired up and within minutes running at full throttle moving quarter million pound aircraft. This takes about ten minutes and then they are again shut off.
This resulted in engine failures, and when factory reps investigated the problem, found excessive amounts of water in the oil sumps. In my recertification, I attended schools instructed by my airline and reps from DD. The fix was not to let the engines cool down, and a mod was installed to run the engines at a fast idle between push backs.
It was the factory rep that told me about the quart per start, and when one engine was drained after a day, it had over half its crankcase filled with water,
Here's a link to Amsoil's web site that describes in depth, cold weather opperating problems. Within the article, you might note that they state, "For every one gallon of gasoline an engine burns, one gallon of water is produced as a by-product. In cold weather water vapor will condense on the cylinder walls and be picked up by the oil. Condensation in engine oil can lead to the formation of sludge, rust and corrosion.":
Posted 2010-12-21 1:26 AM (#128232 - in reply to #128231) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 3853 Location: Vermont
Originally written by gard on 2010-12-20 11:20 PM
Originally written by dgeesaman on 2010-12-20 9:44 PM
Everytime the engine is cold started, over a quart of water is dumped into the crankcase.
I'd like to know the source of this statistic.
When I worked for the airlines, every year we had to be recertified for pushbacks, using tugs to move the aircraft. They were powered by Detroit Diesel motors. Pit weather often drops to zero, and when the tugs are shut of for 45 - 60 mins at a time, they rappidly cool down. Then they are fired up and within minutes running at full throttle moving quarter million pound aircraft. This takes about ten minutes and then they are again shut off.
This resulted in engine failures, and when factory reps investigated the problem, found excessive amounts of water in the oil sumps. In my recertification, I attended schools instructed by my airline and reps from DD. The fix was not to let the engines cool down, and a mod was installed to run the engines at a fast idle between push backs.
It was the factory rep that told me about the quart per start, and when one engine was drained after a day, it had over half its crankcase filled with water,
Here's a link to Amsoil's web site that describes in depth, cold weather opperating problems. Within the article, you might note that they state, "For every one gallon of gasoline an engine burns, one gallon of water is produced as a by-product. In cold weather water vapor will condense on the cylinder walls and be picked up by the oil. Condensation in engine oil can lead to the formation of sludge, rust and corrosion.":
Posted 2010-12-21 4:18 AM (#128233 - in reply to #128231) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Regular
Posts: 92 Location: Harrisburg, PA
Originally written by gard on 2010-12-20 11:20 PM
Originally written by dgeesaman on 2010-12-20 9:44 PM
Everytime the engine is cold started, over a quart of water is dumped into the crankcase.
I'd like to know the source of this statistic.
When I worked for the airlines, every year we had to be recertified for pushbacks, using tugs to move the aircraft. They were powered by Detroit Diesel motors. Pit weather often drops to zero, and when the tugs are shut of for 45 - 60 mins at a time, they rappidly cool down. Then they are fired up and within minutes running at full throttle moving quarter million pound aircraft. This takes about ten minutes and then they are again shut off.
This resulted in engine failures, and when factory reps investigated the problem, found excessive amounts of water in the oil sumps. In my recertification, I attended schools instructed by my airline and reps from DD. The fix was not to let the engines cool down, and a mod was installed to run the engines at a fast idle between push backs.
It was the factory rep that told me about the quart per start, and when one engine was drained after a day, it had over half its crankcase filled with water,
Here's a link to Amsoil's web site that describes in depth, cold weather opperating problems. Within the article, you might note that they state, "For every one gallon of gasoline an engine burns, one gallon of water is produced as a by-product. In cold weather water vapor will condense on the cylinder walls and be picked up by the oil. Condensation in engine oil can lead to the formation of sludge, rust and corrosion.":
Interesting. I've seen cases in industry where water accumulates within the machine (I work with gear reducers on industrial mixers) and for us a simple desiccant breather or sump heater usually stops it. These Detroit diesels must have had very large sections of airspace that drained into the oil sump with very particular thermal cycling of the air temps that could "rain" a quart at a time.
So I agree that condensation is a concern during cold times. But a quart of condensation is extreme and I'm confident that our trucks see orders of magnitude lower than that.
Posted 2010-12-21 8:18 AM (#128235 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 455 Location: Texas
I think the points that everybody has made here are good. The point about moisture in the engine and letting it run long enough to purge the oil of the moisture is good.
I'm a little less paranoid about the battery, though. Your profile says you are from Seattle. It really doesn't get that cold there to have to worry about battery tenders or needing to start the vehicle multiple times per week. Heck, I live in North Dakota, and my pickup will go 3 weeks or a month without being started sometimes. Some tractors sit from October to May without being started, and I only put a battery charger on them a couple times over the winter. As long as the battery has a full charge, the cold doesn't hurt it too bad. Especially when "cold" isn't actually very cold.
Oh, and be careful about finding people to haul stuff for. Pretty soon, the word will get out and you'll never get to use your pickup for your own use.
Posted 2010-12-21 10:21 AM (#128236 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Elite Veteran
Posts: 720
Not an expert, but I would believe that the issues with a Detroit Diesel 2-stroke engine (very old design that has since proven itself not worthy of future development) may be significantly different from a modern 4-stroke like we see in today's trucks. It seems as if those Detroits were a unique breed all their own. Look at one of the largest fleets in the world- UPS. They turn their LD diesels off at every stop. And the big rig diesels you see running- that's because they are sleeping in there and need the heat or A/C. In fact the new trucks will have an APU, Auxiliary Power Unit which is a small engine just for the climate unit so they don't have to run the large engine. So my vote- drive it to the barn every week and you'll be fine assuming it is at least a 30 min drive there. No need to let it idle.
Posted 2010-12-21 10:32 AM (#128237 - in reply to #128235) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Regular
Posts: 95 Location: Seattle "pshaw, its not raining hardly at all!" WA
yeah, I was wondering about our wimpy winters in Seattle and how "cold" isnt really all that cold most of the time. sounds like I may just invest in a pair of super heavy duty jumper cables and a AAA membership (not sure my hybrid has enough oomph to jump start Helga the truck? they both have 2 batteries, but I'll need to do some research on that...)
try to drive her once a week (my Saturdays are usually a trip to the barn and back plus running to the feed store (another 15 miles) and other assorted errands, be sure to take the long way around ;), but the 5 miles to work on city streets (never getting above 30 mph) might do more harm than good.
in short, dont worry, drive her as much as possible, keep the fluids clean and full (I have an appt the first of the year :)) have a plan B if I find the battery discharged and relax :)
its been very educational listening to you guys...
Posted 2010-12-21 10:35 AM (#128238 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 342 Location: Ohio
I would let it idle. It's bad for ANY vehicle gas or diesel to be stopped and restarted shortly thereafter multiple times especially in winter.
If I am working around the farm, driving back and forth between fields and the barn, I will let my diesel high-idle. A mod that I installed that will run the RPM's up to about 12-1300 while idling to prevent coking and maintain operating temps.
Diesels are designed that they will cool down while idling, not heat up like a gas engine.
Drive it to the barn a couple times a week, let it run while you're there and you should be fine. Letting it sit is about one of the worst things you could do to it.
Posted 2010-12-21 10:51 AM (#128239 - in reply to #128236) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 5870 Location: western PA
Originally written by horsey1 on 2010-12-21 11:21 AM
Look at one of the largest fleets in the world- UPS. They turn their LD diesels off at every stop. And the big rig diesels you see running- that's because they are sleeping in there and need the heat or A/C. In fact the new trucks will have an APU, Auxiliary Power Unit which is a small engine just for the climate unit so they don't have to run the large engine. So my vote- drive it to the barn every week and you'll be fine assuming it is at least a 30 min drive there. No need to let it idle.
The UPS trucks are specifically designed for their intended usage. Compared to open road vehicles, their motors are undersized. By working harder, they are always within their optium operating temperatures. This creates an efficient, fuel saving running cycle. When they are shut down, it is for a very short time period, and the engines don't cool off. The starters are heavy duty units, specifically designed for the high cycling, used daily.
Many states now have laws, making it unlawful to idle diesel trucks for anything exceeding five minutes. This time allows the turbo units to cool off before shut down, a very important issue for component longevity. These laws are to reduce air pollution. As was stated, instead of running a large engine at idle for heat, a smaller motor is used that produces less pollutants and uses less fuel. In addition, many large truck stops now have plug in shore services, that supply all the trucker's needs while his truck's engine is shut down.
Thirty minutes of driving is a good recommendation. It allows enough time to fully warm things up, evaporate the water from the combustion areas and oil supply and fully recharge the batteries.
Posted 2010-12-21 11:01 AM (#128240 - in reply to #128239) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Regular
Posts: 95 Location: Seattle "pshaw, its not raining hardly at all!" WA
Originally written by gard on 2010-12-21 8:51 AM.
Thirty minutes of driving is a good recommendation. It allows enough time to fully warm things up, evaporate the water from the combustion areas and oil supply and fully recharge the batteries.
thanks for the clear recommendations from you all....I was kinda starting to wonder if you guys defined "short" and "cold" a bit differently than I did!
30 minutes will get me to barn. If there's no traffic, I may take the scenic route so it takes longer ;) (heck, if I leave at 4pm on a weekday, it will take me 1.5 hrs. whee! did I mention the toll bridge they're putting in this spring? hmm. now that I think on it, avoiding the toll bridge will DEFINATELY put me at 1/2 hr....)
Posted 2010-12-21 2:17 PM (#128243 - in reply to #128240) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 1351 Location: Decatur, Texas
Originally written by ornerie on 2010-12-21 11:01 AM
Originally written by gard on 2010-12-21 8:51 AM.
Thirty minutes of driving is a good recommendation. It allows enough time to fully warm things up, evaporate the water from the combustion areas and oil supply and fully recharge the batteries.
thanks for the clear recommendations from you all....I was kinda starting to wonder if you guys defined "short" and "cold" a bit differently than I did!
30 minutes will get me to barn. If there's no traffic, I may take the scenic route so it takes longer ;) (heck, if I leave at 4pm on a weekday, it will take me 1.5 hrs. whee! did I mention the toll bridge they're putting in this spring? hmm. now that I think on it, avoiding the toll bridge will DEFINATELY put me at 1/2 hr....)
anyway, thank you! all of you!
I did a little research on www.cumminsforum.com and found that either driving it to the barn ever so often or just disconnect the batteries you will be fine. Don't let people scare you away with talk about Detroit diesels (they are totally different animals when it come to diesel) Can not even come close to compairing them to Cummins diesels.
If you get time go to www.cumminsforum.com and there is a section just for 1994 to 1998.5 trucks.
Posted 2010-12-21 9:16 PM (#128254 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Member
Posts: 25 Location: Canada
We have a 2007 F-350 King Ranch that gets used once every two weeks to take garbage to the dump and for the odd winter trek with the horse trailer. Dump run takes about half an hour (with a run through the drive through at Tim
Hortons for a double double of course!) The truck starts great even in the dead of the Canadian winter, (-20's) and I have a horrible habit of not plugging it in... The truck is almost 4 years old and it only has 25,000 miles on it, and knock of wood, still runs great!
Posted 2010-12-23 3:06 AM (#128268 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Regular
Posts: 95 Location: Seattle "pshaw, its not raining hardly at all!" WA
just so the data is here in case anyone needs to search on it later...
it took Helga a good 20 min at highway speeds to get her temp guage up to half way and her battery charge guage up to 3/4. this is with an ambient temp of 50 degrees, and not having been run for about 2 weeks.
that said, after running into the feedstore for a 1/2 or so (crazy holiday shopping time at the feed store, apparently...), she started up just as warm as she had been when I stopped, so I figure the engine block was nice and toasty :).
I also noted that my GPS apparently stays on even with the truck shut down. need to remember to unplug that bad boy totally or I might come back at the end of a long weekend to find my battery dead!
Posted 2010-12-23 8:50 AM (#128269 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 5870 Location: western PA
At an ambient temperature of 50 degrees F, most of these discussions are a moot point. Drive and store your diesel as you would your car. You don't need extended idling or special starting considerations.
It's only when the temperatures fall below freezing, reaching zero or below, that starting and running a diesel involves different techniques than a gas motor.
We had a simple rule of thumb that worked well while using diesel powered equipment: Never run the motor when it's cold, never put it away when it's hot. Always allow the motor to warm up before pulling power, never shut it down until it has cooled off. This is especially important with turbo equiped motors. Used with moderation, these motors can last many people decades of use.
Posted 2010-12-23 11:17 AM (#128270 - in reply to #128205) Subject: RE: minimum truck use?
Expert
Posts: 3802 Location: Rocky Mount N.C.
Our world has $3.00 gasoline and $3.25 diesel this morning..... Not going to leaving much of anything sitting around running unattended.... Didn't check the price of off road diesel fuel, bet it won't miss much from being three bucks!!!...... Merry Christmas.