Posted 2006-05-31 9:44 AM (#42435) Subject: Battery Recharging Problems
Member
Posts: 38
Location: Howard Cty, MD
I have a non-LQ 34' GN trailer with 2 batteries setup to power the electric-hydraulic jack, 3 load lights (about 55 watts ea), 4 fans (each draws about 1.4 amps), 4 lights in the horse area, 2 lights in the dressing room area, LED marker & stop lights, 2 exterior 'porch' lights and 2 lighted grab handles. I've had the trailer for about 5 months now and have hauled it several times. Recently, I used 3 of the fans for about 4 hours while I was camped and another 2 hours while hauling. When I was unhooking the trailer at the end of the day, I noticed that the jack was moving rather slowly & that the interior horse area lights were not as bright as I remembered. I unhooked one of the batteries, brought it to the house and attached my BatteryMinder plus recharger to it. It ran for almost 24 hours without going into maintenance mode.The batteries are new, I haven't found any blown fuses, and usually turn off lights when no longer needed.
I called the trailer manufacturer and he stated that they are starting to see similar problems with the bigger trailers without living quarters. His hypothesis is that the truck is unable to supply enough amps to the trailer's recharging system while hauling because of all the things that are running (truck lights, trailer marker lights, radio, etc.). I have a 2003 F350 V-10. He recommends that I connect a regular battery recharger unit to the batteries and then use a trickle charger while the trailer sits, consider a 110V converter and/or look into a solar panel powered recharger that can be hooked up all the time.
My questions are these: Are others having similar experiences with their truck being unable to keep the batteries charged? What system do you use to keep your batteries charged? Is a permanently attached solar panel recharger worth the cost and effort to install? Any other thoughts?
Posted 2006-05-31 10:05 AM (#42438 - in reply to #42435) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Expert
Posts: 2954
Location: North Carolina
A regular battery charger is a good suggestion. You have a large battery capacity. I would not depend on the truck to charge the trailer batteries. I would (and did) keep the maintenance charger on the trailer batteries when parked at home. Then, you'll have a fully charged set when ever you leave.
The truck can only charge the batteries while it's running down the road. Just idling, the charging system is not at full capacity. So if you used the batteries for lights and jack( high draw) and took two hours driving home, the batteries only got 2 hours of charging. Simply ... not enough charging time or current.
Posted 2006-05-31 10:18 AM (#42439 - in reply to #42435) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 366
Location: Albany, Oregon
I would check and make sure the truck is charging the trailer batteries when it is running. Use a voltmeter (check thr trailer batteries with the truck off then check with truck running) or when the loading lights are dim start the truck and they should get brighter. If it appears your truck is charging the trailer batteries I would say you arn't on the road long enough to fully charge the batteries. 3 fans=4.2amps is a fair draw over time! The jack will really zap the batteries...3 load lights = 13 amps! It starts to add up! A fix would be either a dedicated battery tender or a small 20W(bigger if you have the funds) solar panel to keep them fresh. I like the solar because it still works if you forget to plug it in. Both will just maintain the batteries so they are fresh when you go to use the trailer. Of course you will have to ration your amps carefully. A perminent voltmeter is a handy tool to see how much use you have left in your batteries .
Posted 2006-05-31 11:25 AM (#42443 - in reply to #42435) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Expert
Posts: 2689
"New batteries" aren't necessarily "good new storage batteries".
If you have been sold "car/truck STARTER batteries" you cannot expect to use them as deep cycle storage batteries.
You could do the arithmetic on ampere hours consumed vs recharge time on the way to camp site and home. Also remember that the trailer batteries are at the end of a (relatively) long thin wire, which has some resistance - a lot more than the fat cable between the alternator and the truck's (starter) batteries. There will be some voltage drop.
The truck can almost certainly provide enough current, but it will be voltage limited by the truck's batteries and alternator's regulator AT THE TRUCK ! The difference between that regulated voltage and your trailer batteries' terminal voltage, the batteries' internal resistance and the wiring path's resistance will determine the charging rate.
because V=IR (-:
Posted 2006-05-31 10:19 PM (#42476 - in reply to #42435) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Member
Posts: 38
Location: Howard Cty, MD
Thanks for the help. I bought a Schumacher SE-1275A battery charger at the auto parts store today and have hooked it up to the batteries (one at a time). It seems to be recharging the batteries ok, however the neddle jumps around a lot when I first hook it up and then after a few hours. Not sure if the unit is working correctly or if it's defective. Time will tell.
Posted 2006-06-01 9:47 AM (#42491 - in reply to #42476) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 366
Location: Albany, Oregon
Originally written by TXAggie on 2006-05-31 8:19 PM
I bought a Schumacher SE-1275A battery charger at the auto parts store today and have hooked it up to the batteries (one at a time).
Make sure it will not overcharge the batteries...You can boil the water out if you leave it hooked up to long! The battery tender type will float when fully charged and not overcharge the batteries.
Posted 2006-06-01 2:00 PM (#42503 - in reply to #42435) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Veteran
Posts: 225
Location: Kansas City
Pop the top on the batteries and make sure the acid levels are over the lead plates. They could have been filled improperly or could have been boiled off, as noted, by someone charging the batteries before you. If dry or low, you have a couple of options including adding acid, maybe distilled water, or most likely buying a new battery.
Posted 2006-06-01 2:10 PM (#42504 - in reply to #42503) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Expert
Posts: 2689
Originally written by barry on 2006-06-01 2:00 PM
Pop the top on the batteries and make sure the acid levels are over the lead plates. They could have been filled improperly or could have been boiled off, as noted, by someone charging the batteries before you. If dry or low, you have a couple of options including adding acid, maybe distilled water, or most likely buying a new battery.
Adding acid is only an option if acid has left, e.g. by spilling.
Methinks that hydrogen and oxygen (the major constituents of WATER) are the only things that leave as a consequnce of charging.
Posted 2006-06-02 12:14 PM (#42560 - in reply to #42504) Subject: RE: Battery Recharging Problems
Veteran
Posts: 225
Location: Kansas City
Originally written by Reg on 2006-06-01 2:10 PM
Originally written by barry on 2006-06-01 2:00 PM
Pop the top on the batteries and make sure the acid levels are over the lead plates. They could have been filled improperly or could have been boiled off, as noted, by someone charging the batteries before you. If dry or low, you have a couple of options including adding acid, maybe distilled water, or most likely buying a new battery.
Adding acid is only an option if acid has left, e.g. by spilling.
Methinks that hydrogen and oxygen (the major constituents of WATER) are the only things that leave as a consequnce of charging.
I think you are correct. However, in the charging process someone could have boiled/overcharged the battery and caused the acid to "spill" out. I am used to having access to a parts store that stocks "battery acid" and I personally favor adding the original stuff when I've found a battery "dry" or "low."
All that said, I generally think when you have battery problems you might as well buy new batteries cause sometime somewhere they will leave you in a lurch.