|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | I'm new to pulling a GN trailer and have a 3/4 F250 diesel and pull a 21' trailet with it. There is alot of bounce in the truck from the trailer - I'm wondering if the neck needs to be adjusted to make the front higher. Any ideas why there'd be so much "bounce" in the truck from the trailer? |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1416
Location: sc | Are your shocks in good shape? Since youre "new", how do you know there is a lot of bounce? Know anyone experienced for a second opinion? |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA | When the truck is sitting statically, are the blocks on the rear springs touching the helper springs? Or is there a small space between the blocks and spring ends? If the load varies on and off the helper springs, sometimes you can get a bouncing motion on uneven road surfaces. Or if you have a particularly heavy load with a stock suspension, when the springs are heavily loaded, they can bounce on and off the axle blocks, again on an uneven road. Most overload devices, air bags, Timbrens etc will prevent this from happening. You may also have worn out shocks in the back. Many OEM shocks have short life spans and need to be replaced early on. Most replacement units have a life time warranty. You didn't mention how old your truck was and if the rear suspension is in good repair. We run the nose of our trailers 3"-4" high at the hitch. Unless your hitch is so high that the front axle is almost off the ground, I doubt that this would be a cause of your problem. I assume that your trailer is not nose low, which would increase the weight on the front axle and make the trailer behave erratically. Check your rig empty and loaded on a level surface to determine the actual pitch. Check your tire pressures and at least have the rear tires inflated to the maximum sidewall rating. You will need good quality "E" range LT tires. Your trailer is not abnormally heavy, and your truck should easily handle the load. Check those items and perhaps you will find your problem. Gard |
|
|
|
Veteran
Posts: 182
| Is it power hopping? I have had that happen before when I towed a load. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 3853
Location: Vermont | Originally written by karynzoo on 2008-05-18 6:33 PM I'm new to pulling a GN trailer and have a 3/4 F250 diesel and pull a 21' trailet with it. There is alot of bounce in the truck from the trailer - I'm wondering if the neck needs to be adjusted to make the front higher. Any ideas why there'd be so much "bounce" in the truck from the trailer? Need more details... When is it bouncing? When stopping? When starting? While driving?...Does it happen when you drive over the expansion strips?
Edited by PaulChristenson 2008-05-18 8:09 PM
|
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | My truck is a 2004 (shortbed crewcab)and I haven't checked the springs but I certainly will. I bought it with 14k on it and it was like new, never pulled anything. My friend has a newer gas F250 and said her new goosneck does not do that to her truck. The trailer pulls straight. When I'm on the road and there are little bumps/grooves in the road it gets really bumpy in the truck. When I bought it and drove it home from Indiana (about 100 mi) I got alot of bumping from the road - it was actually pretty bad. For an example when you see those older cars that have bad shocks when they go over a bump and the back end is going up and down that's what it felt like inside the truck. The people that had it before me had it adjusted for a taller truck so I'm thinking I need to drop the nose about 2-3 inches but want to get on level to see.
The bumps that cause it aren't large ones just the smaller ones that are close in proximity that seem to do it. The more there are the worse it gets. Sorry but I'm gooseneck illiterate right now so any info appreciated. What is power hopping?
Edited by karynzoo 2008-05-18 8:52 PM
|
|
|
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 402
Location: Lockport, Illinois | Where is the gooseneck hitch in your truck? in front of, on the, or behind the rear axle. You stated you have a short bed, in a 8'bed the gooseneck hitch is mounted 4" ahead of the rear axle, mounting it this way the weight is distributed to both axles, which gives you a better ride than mounting it on or behind the rear axle. Adjusting the gooseneck tube will only add or subtract the clearance between the truck and the gooseneck nose and level the trailer. Adjusting your load in the trailer would add or subtract from the pin (the amount of weight that is on your gooseneck ball)), a horse ahead of the axles would increase your pin weight and a horse behind the axle would decrease your pin weight.
Edited by BigT 2008-05-18 9:46 PM
|
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | It's in front of the axle, not sure how far but I'd say about 3-4". It was put in by a local trailer shop. I hauled my 1 horse in the second slant (3hrs slant) and it was better but still bouncy. It was horrible empty. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 3853
Location: Vermont | Check your shocks...They seem to have lost their damping...
Edited by PaulChristenson 2008-05-18 11:09 PM
|
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 83
Location: Cheshire England | Im with the shocks its said that they should be checked after 30 thousand miles you could look to see if any are leaking oil and the rubber bushes are ok, but i would fit some HD aftermarket shocks anyway, good luck and happy hauling
Edited by perfect11s 2008-05-19 1:53 AM
|
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | I'll have the shocks checked out, I'm wondering if they're just underrated or something. PS - thanks everyone for the comments.
Edited by karynzoo 2008-05-19 8:02 AM
|
|
|
|
New User
Posts: 3
Location: Southwest Indiana | Hi karynzoo, Like you, I'm rather new at pulling my 3-horse GN - 1 year under my belt. I pull with a 3/4 GMC. The first time I pulled the trailer it bounced pretty bad. We lowered the front a bit and worked on the air pressure in the tires of the trailer. That did the trick and we travel smoothly down the highway now. Good luck - you'll love the GN |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | Hey...I'm game to try anything that isn't going to cost me more money. I do need to check the tires as they seem low to me and I know the neck needs to come down about 2-3 inches. gotta start somewhere but stillw want to check out the truck and get everything I can while it is under warranty! |
|
|
|
Location: north central tx | This may sound a little crazy to some. I have witnessed first hand a p.u. that bounced so violently down the highway. .You could see daylight under both the back wheels. (50mph) There was a knot on one of the back tires. Since your p.u. does not have many miles, it may be old new tires. Hope this helps.
Edited by 30wheeler 2008-05-19 11:10 PM
|
|
|
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 385
Location: washington | My old gooseneck didn't cause the truck to bounce, but it did tug all the time, making it feel like the brakes were always being tapped. Usually this was when the trailer was empty. It felt more like constant tugging. My new gooseneck does not do that. It may be due to a little different tongue weight or overall balance of the trailer. I never did figure out what caused the other GN to do that. |
|
|
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 362
Location: Allegan, Michigan | I would invest in some air ride bags. We had some put on about a month ago and boy did they make a HUGE difference. We pull with a F250 4x4 crewcab long bed diesel (2004). We have found our mileage has been better as well and the ride is alot smoother. |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | I was actually doing some research on air bags to see if that would be the best thing to do. I'm taking it by my trailer guy for suggestions on Thursday. I'm going to start with the tire pressure and adjusting the neck as I know it's currently adjusted for a much taller truck. thanks everyone. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 3853
Location: Vermont | Originally written by 30wheeler on 2008-05-19 11:54 PM This may sound a little crazy to some. I have witnessed first hand a p.u. that bounced so violently down the highway. .You could see daylight under both the back wheels. (50mph ) There was a knot on one of the back tires. Since your p.u. does not have many miles, it may be old new tires. Hope this helps. VIDEO...WE WANT VIDEO... |
|
|
|
Veteran
Posts: 112
Location: Bow, NH | Your trailer is not that big and an F250 should be more than capable of handling it. I have not seen anyone mention having the trailer axles checked!! Did you say the trailer was new or used? Also, check the tires on both the truck and trailer. On occassion I've gotten major vibration when towing and both times it turned out that one of the trailer tires had had a belt come loose. Again, I would say have the axles and tires checked. Hope this helps!! |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | I did the trailer checked out but was extremly dissatisfied with the trailer place I used for other reasons and have been questioning everything they've done since.... I take it to my regular trailer guy who is expensive but very thorough tomorrow. Hopefully it's something simple. |
|
|
|
Elite Veteran
Posts: 720
| Adjust the neck, adjust the neck, adjust the neck. Until you do, the rear axle is overloaded and will ride horrible. Do this first. |
|
|
|
Veteran
Posts: 216
Location: Chillicothe, Ohio | My F350superduty longbed does this on some highways with certain expansion joint spacing between the concrete. Hauling a 4 horse sooner. It has something to do with the truck tires and the trailer tires hitting the spaces just at some certain frequency. I have tried several things to correct it with no success. Never have this issue even on gravel roads, or going over bridge joints etc. |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | Trailer guy say's " your truck is squatting and the trailer is adjusted pretty level and you need heavy duty springs" He suggested the springs instead of the air bags as he said you always have to fiddle with the air bags. He also mentioned that Ford is notorious for putting softier springs in the SD trucks. He's got a F350 himself. Found that my tire pressure on the truck is low so I'll take care of that. He didn't mention shocks. He couldn't guarantee that it would be an end all cure all but would certainly help the situation. Anyone tried this route? results? Note - Spring guy thought it might be better to put 2 leafs in the springs to get the stability while towing while keeping the ride when not more comfortable. Still not sure what to do...more research.
Edited by karynzoo 2008-05-22 1:48 PM
|
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1416
Location: sc | I would try some Timbrens before I went messing with the spring pack. Exactly how heavy is this trailer? |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | Wow......that's funny. I just got off the phone with the big truck place down the road and he suggested that as well. I'm going to fix the tire pressure situation, drop the neck down about 1-2" to be conservative and go down the road (they're close thank goodness) and check them out at their place. He swears by them and did not reccomend beefing up the springs with either leafs or replacement HD's due to the ride. 28' overall, living quarter, 3 horse I'd say chocked full with 3 horses, tack, hay, etc...it's probably about 11000+
Edited by karynzoo 2008-05-22 2:10 PM
|
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA | Beefing up the springs or adding air bags will change the ride of an unloaded truck. A "spring" system like a Timbren, which I have, leaves the original ride unchanged and only works during a loaded situation. Once the truck "squats" to a predetermined level, it will not settle any more. There are no air adjustments or any maintenance of any kind. I have a SD Ford and regardless of what trailer I pull, there is no bouncing or handling issues. Your truck rear tire pressures should be at the maximum capacity as stated on the sidewalls. Gard |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | Thanks all. Got'em ordered to install next week. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1416
Location: sc | Originally written by karynzoo on 2008-05-22 9:09 PM Thanks all. Got'em ordered to install next week. Let us know what you think after you get them. |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | So what kind of clearance should I see on the Timberlins and should I let them put the spacers in? I don't want a rough ride unloaded!!! |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1416
Location: sc | 1" IIRC. I would not/did not put the spacers on mine. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA | The Timbrens on our truck are set so the helper springs just touch the blocks when the Timbrens touch the frame. This allows a completely stock ride when empty and a consistent ride level when loaded. You do not want the Timbrens to interfere with the unloaded ride. It would be an uncomfortable situation. Gard |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1416
Location: sc | http://www.timbren.com/timbren-application-guides/application-pdfs/FR250SDE.pdf |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | I don't know what's going on but the ride empty is HORRIBLE - very bouncy like I need a seat belt just to stay in the seat. What did they do wrong when they installed them? This has to be adjusted...HELP I do think there is some kind of adjustment they can make as it notes it on the website it just isn't clear. Does anyone have any suggestions? I have them on my F250/sd
The mechanic said there IS a spacer (WHEW!) so they'll pull it tomorrow and I should get the soft unloaded ride again.
I tow on Friday so hoping the stability during towing is good.
Edited by karynzoo 2008-06-04 9:01 AM
|
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | Update - I've got quite a few trips under my belt with the Timbren's. The truck isn't sagging hardly at all in the back and when my horse is loaded it hardly bounces at all - pulls nice and straight. BUT - if the trailer is empty that's a different story. One person described it pretty clearly that when you have bumps in the road and the truck's back wheels and trailer's wheels hit it at different intervals the trailer bounces and the neck bounces the back of the truck something fierce. When I took it to have a few things added to it my son actually said he started feeling nauseous from the bouncing. He was sure glad we got on the highway where the road was smoother. I have new tires on the truck and trailer, the trailer pulls straight so either there is something with the suspension with the trailer or I need something more on the truck. I may need new shocks, I have no idea. A couple of the trailer places thought the air bags would perform better but the mechanic I use thought my shocks were weak. These are all "thoughts" so until I get it figured out my mare and I will have to deal with the bouncing. Thank goodness it is minimal to non-existant when she's loaded. You can actually see the back end of the trailer bounce a bit and then it just back lashes to the back of the truck, that's when you wanna toss your cookies....LOL Still not sure how to fix this, I really hate to pull the Timbren's and put air bags on if that's not the cure. I'd hate to put HD springs on too. Shocks would be the best solution if that truly is the solution. I hate this stuff.
Edited by karynzoo 2008-08-12 11:15 AM
|
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 3802
Location: Rocky Mount N.C. | Did you remove the spacers? |
|
|
|
Location: Where the wind comes sweepin' down the plain... | I had an area here that would do the same thing to me. Old concrete interstate...hitting expansion joints would push and pull so much it would hurt...unless I was loaded. Both of my trailers were that way in that one area. With more than one truck. It was a wheel base thing. I could run through there with a reg cab and not have it happen, but with both crew cabs you had to strap yourself in, pull down your hat, and hold on tight. Last year they ground the surface of the road getting ready to resurface and as soon as they ground the surface, it stopped. |
|
|
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 350
Location: Newton, NJ | 28' Trailet, LQ 3horse with tack and animals... I'd say have it weighed. Bet you're over 11K and that might be the issue. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1391
Location: North of Detroit, MI | Originally written by Tresvolte on 2008-08-12 12:48 PM
I had an area here that would do the same thing to me. Old concrete interstate...hitting expansion joints would push and pull so much it would hurt...unless I was loaded. Both of my trailers were that way in that one area. With more than one truck. It was a wheel base thing. I could run through there with a reg cab and not have it happen, but with both crew cabs you had to strap yourself in, pull down your hat, and hold on tight. Last year they ground the surface of the road getting ready to resurface and as soon as they ground the surface, it stopped. That's what I've experienced with several of my F150s with extended cab & 6.75 bed (144.5" wheelbase). Didn't matter if I was towing a BP or a GN... when they are empty, it's wicked -when loaded, it's still bad but not as much. backward and forward tugging. Did it with the old style suspension and the new (2006 and newer) suspension. It's as though my truck suspension would bounce and then the trailer would bounce and put a instant drag on the truck just as it was hitting the next "crack". I tried running at 80 mph and down to 55 mph (unloaded)... the faster speed was better, but I felt too out of control. |
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 3802
Location: Rocky Mount N.C. | (Quote gabz)... the faster speed was better, but I felt too out of control. Yea, you were just catching the very tip-top of those expansion joints!! |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | I only haul 1 horse so it's I doubt it's 12k but i should weigh it to check it out. What you all are describing is exactly the issue - I've got a short bed f250 diesel 04 (yes the dreaded 6.0) and my trailer as noted is 21' on the floor 28' overall with neck - 7 wide 7'4' tall trailet 3 horse LQ with a 6' short wall. I don't keep a ton of stuff in it other than my tack and some essentials up front then of course when I go I load up my horse. I just know empty it's rough and you really need to hold on sometimes. Stuff in my back tack area was thrown all over when I drove it empty the last time but then I drove it like there was no horse in it too. I don't honestly know what if anything would fix this. I guess I just need to take it hooked up to a horse trailer place, let them drive it and see what suggestions they may have. Since this is my daily driver vehicle I'd hate to firm up the ride for that. Yes - they took the spacer out of the timbrens - the ride while not hooked up is back to normal. I know my friend has a chevy short bed crew cab and pulls a similar size trailer and doesn't have these problems. So it just got me wondering what gives....??? I used to pull a 18' bumper pull previously - never had this problem pulled straight hardly knew it was back there. Didn't matter if it was empty or loaded.
Edited by karynzoo 2008-08-12 2:05 PM
|
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 5870
Location: western PA | Originally written by karynzoo on 2008-08-12 12:10 PM Update - I've got quite a few trips under my belt with the Timbren's. The truck isn't sagging hardly at all in the back and when my horse is loaded it hardly bounces at all - pulls nice and straight. BUT - if the trailer is empty that's a different story. One person described it pretty clearly that when you have bumps in the road and the truck's back wheels and trailer's wheels hit it at different intervals the trailer bounces and the neck bounces the back of the truck something fierce. . Thank goodness it is minimal to non-existant when she's loaded. You can actually see the back end of the trailer bounce a bit and then it just back lashes to the back of the truck, that's when you wanna toss your cookies....LOL Still not sure how to fix this, I really hate to pull the Timbren's and put air bags on if that's not the cure. I'd hate to put HD springs on too. Shocks would be the best solution if that truly is the solution. You keep mentioning that it is the trailer which is bouncing when it is unloaded, and that things are better when it's loaded. It sounds as if the trailer tires may be over inflated? Changing to airbags from your Timbrens should have little affect on the ride of an unloaded rig. While it's unloaded, the Timbrens should not even be touching the frame. Heavy duty springs will make the already harsh ride even more so, loaded or empty. The Timbrens are keeping your ride height correct and contribute to a good ride under a load. They're doing what they're supposed to do. There are sections of our local roads that cause one of my trailers to start a porpoising action, but not the other. The other trailer has a longer wheelbase, and the cyclic, porpoising motion is not present as a result. If the truck is being jostled about by the trailer, weak shocks could contribute to the truck's mimicking of the lashing frequency of the trailer. If your truck is a few years old and has some miles, a new set of rear shocks may help. The OEMs generally are not long lived, and the new aftermarket replacements, have life time warranties and generally are constructed much better. Another thing to check is the tire pressure of your rear tires for correct inflation. They should be OK if you're good under a load, but they may also be overinflated, causing a harsh ride when empty. Gard |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 73
Location: Decatur, Texas | Shortbed Fords are bad about that. They use soft springs to make it a family or daily driver. Buy you a set of FIRESTONE airbags and spend the extra money for the incab controller and pump! I have used them on every truck I have bought. I have a new Dodge 3500 quad cab c/c with a 12.5-k gvrw and even installed at set on it and keep them at 40psi or so empty and 75psi loaded. Even made a difference unlaoded on mine. If you install extra springs, you will hate it unloaded it will ride like grandfather's farm wagon. good luck |
|
|
|
Member
Posts: 5
Location: Preston, Idaho | Is your bounce worse when you are loaded or un-loaded? Does the trailer have torsion axles on it and what size are they? What size is your trailer? |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | c.will_09 - you hit the nail on the head with this one! Ford definately softened up the suspension on these trucks making them great for daily drivers but not so good for hauling with weight on the axle. I'm still torn between air bags and shocks. The money it would cost to do the air bags with the onboard air is pretty costly and my budget doesn't allow for that right now and would be hesitant to do it w/o the air onboard. I'm definately not doing HD springs as I don't want to get beat to death driving around town unhooked. I'm still letting all this "Marinate" while I start saving to get 'er done.
|
|
|
|
Expert
Posts: 1391
Location: North of Detroit, MI | Originally written by c.will_09 on 2008-08-12 12:18 AM Shortbed Fords are bad about that. They use soft springs to make it a family or daily driver. Buy you a set of FIRESTONE airbags and spend the extra money for the incab controller and pump! I have used them on every truck I have bought. I have a new Dodge 3500 quad cab c/c with a 12.5-k gvrw and even installed at set on it and keep them at 40psi or so empty and 75psi loaded. Even made a difference unlaoded on mine. If you install extra springs, you will hate it unloaded it will ride like grandfather's farm wagon. good luck The 2004 and newer F150s, and then a year or two later they changed the 250/350s, have the super stiff suspension. That's when they moved the shocks... and right now I cannot remember if they moved them IN or OUT in relation to the springs. These are NOT soft suspension. My F150 bounces off a dirt road if I have no load in it. 144.5" wheelbase (extended cab with 6.75 bed). Maybe getting a newer truck would be cheapest solution? |
|
|
|
Extreme Veteran
Posts: 346
| My truck bounces too but probably got something to do with the 75mph to 80 speed |
|
|
|
Regular
Posts: 52
Location: Elgin, IL | A newer truck isn't in the picture and wouldn't be cost effective since my truck is loaded to the hilt inside. I just couldn't afford the 45k it would cost to replace it right now. $1000 for the air bags with onboard air is definately cheaper. Even if I (gulp) have to do the HD springs that's 500 bucks, shocks are a little less. Whenever I DO get to that point you bet I'll be getting a dually either dodge or Ford diesel. Of course at that point it will NOT be my daily driving vehicle and it'll definately be a long bed. Then I'll be ready for my next trailer!! Note - that is interesting about the shocks. I will have to say I checked with the Ford Mechanic and he did advise the suspension is not as firm on the 04's due to alot of people wanting them as daily driving vehicles rather than towing vehicles. They did change that later on but I'm not sure what year. My eyes have really been opened to what to look for in my next tow vehicle. I still like my truck and will have to make it work for now. I suppose I should look into trading up to maybe a SRW 1ton especially with the economy what it is but I just dread paying on a vehicle that long. |
|
|