Question for Gear Heads
Keith Hickam
Reg. Nov 2006
Posted 2006-12-24 7:39 AM (#52818)
Subject: Question for Gear Heads


Member


Posts: 6

Location: Waco, TX

What is the difference in a rebuilt engine and an overhauled one?  Is one more likely to last longer?  What are the cost savings by using one over the other?

Just Curious - I had to sell one of my best dogs to get the money to do this?  On one hand I have friends that I trust saying I should get a low mile used F-150 with an I-6 300 CID and use that one.

Other friends that I trust have advised getting a overhaul or rebuilt engine in my current truck 1993 F-250 Supercab 4X4 with a 460 CID engine in it.  I have in the past 18 months rebuilt the front end, rebuilt the transmission and had a new transfer case put in it.

Just wondering - The only reason I am asking is that I routinely pull (3-5 week) a loaded two horse trailer anywhere from 30 miles to 300 or more - taking my dogs and horses to field trials, where I run my dogs.  I am not a rich pro - but until my 460 started acting up was satisfied with it.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
racesarabhorses
Reg. Oct 2005
Posted 2006-12-24 8:46 AM (#52819 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Veteran


Posts: 254
1001002525
Location: Dickinson, TX

Keep your truck vs go to something with less oomph?

Keep your truck!!

I can't answer your question on rebuilt vs overhauled, but would never trade a truck that'll do what you want to do for something that has less engine, less suspension, and less capability.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Broken Bit
Reg. Jan 2006
Posted 2006-12-24 8:48 AM (#52820 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads



Veteran


Posts: 246
10010025
Location: Northern IN.
Someone may correct me if I'm wrong, but, I went to school for a Diesel Tech. and worked in the field for 3 yrs. as a mechanic and we used the terms interchangeably.  Both the same thing to us.  As for the choice between your trucks, I personally would rebuild (overhaul) the engine in the F-250.  I would not think twice about it especially with all the other new parts on it.  Least ya know what you've got instead of "inheriting" someone elses problems and maybee starting all over again with the tranny, front end, and who knows what.  That's my opinion.  Talk to y'all later...
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
iCE CRM
Reg. Jan 2005
Posted 2006-12-24 2:09 PM (#52824 - in reply to #52820)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Extreme Veteran


Posts: 379
100100100252525
Location: Columbia, TN
I would have the old motor reworked then you can tell them how you want it done. Some remafactures cut corners , if you get a factory rebuilt, say Ford or GM better than most. You are right overhauled rebuilt and remanufactured are interchangeable terms as far as I know.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
TIMEIT
Reg. Dec 2005
Posted 2006-12-24 3:57 PM (#52825 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Member


Posts: 26
25
Location: mt. juliet, tennessee
Look into a Jasper Rebuilt engine......g
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
huntseat
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-12-24 11:17 PM (#52836 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Expert


Posts: 1989
1000500100100100100252525
Location: South Central OK

I thought they were the same but my "Yankee" family uses the terms to indicate the degrees of new parts.  Here in Texas it's the same.  (Could be age dependant too.)

You may find a low mileage engine from a salvage situation too. Ask around to see if this is an option.

Got a rebuilt motor from CA...I think the company was Sunshine, or something.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
huntseat
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2006-12-24 11:22 PM (#52837 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Expert


Posts: 1989
1000500100100100100252525
Location: South Central OK

OK, off the phone with the "Yanks" and they say an overhauled engine is your engine and a rebuilt is one they replace yours with...this is just one ooooooold mans opinion, take it for what it's worth.

Make sure if you get one in that you get credit($) for sending yours back and having it rebuilt...sometimes the shop keeps this for themselves!

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hounddog
Reg. Dec 2005
Posted 2006-12-25 2:57 AM (#52839 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Expert


Posts: 1205
1000100100
Location: Danielsville Georgia
The terms here is a REMAN that goes through a FACTORY TYPE assembly line.Most moving parts replaced,all specs are redone from internal out.A OVERHAULED is replacing some wear items like bearings,rings,re doing valves and guides.REMANS are NEW valves,lifters,cams,rockers,pushrods etc.As some one else mentioned go with a Jasper reman or another high quality reman is ATK of North America.But theres is a differance between overhauled or rebuilt and a REMAN part or new.Call a BIG FORD dealer and price a new also.Sometimes the price of new is not much differant then remans.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Keith Hickam
Reg. Nov 2006
Posted 2006-12-25 8:09 AM (#52842 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Member


Posts: 6

Location: Waco, TX

Thanks everyone - I know the ins and out's of training bird dogs - but when it comes to things mechanical - unless it is irrigation systems - I am lost.

 

 

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Brkncircle
Reg. Nov 2006
Posted 2006-12-27 11:08 AM (#52912 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Member


Posts: 14

Location: Gobles, MI
I have a Jasper rebuilt in my farm truck (1983 F350 dually) and love it. I do not know about their gas engines but when I put this 6.9 diesel in, it came with a 100,000 mile warranty. We work the heck out of this old truck and she just keeps going. The warranty may be something to check on.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hounddog
Reg. Dec 2005
Posted 2006-12-27 3:28 PM (#52922 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads


Expert


Posts: 1205
1000100100
Location: Danielsville Georgia
Actually you have a Jasper REMAN.Thats why it has a 100k warranty,lol. The differant terms actually have a meaning in whats done to a part or engine,trans etc.I believe the differant terms are in the dictionary.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
SLICKRNSNOT
Reg. May 2006
Posted 2006-12-27 8:37 PM (#52936 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads



Elite Veteran


Posts: 671
5001002525
Location: THE GREAT NORTHWET, OREGON(THE REAL GODS COUNTRY)
And then there is the "RECONDITIONED" one.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
efaubert1
Reg. Feb 2004
Posted 2006-12-27 10:11 PM (#52944 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads



Elite Veteran


Posts: 634
50010025
Location: Tipton, IN

  www.jasperengines.com

Remanufactured 460/7.5L for your truck is going to run about $2900 according to their price sheet. They also sell install kits with new hoses, plugs, wires, water pump, clamps, and other extras you'll need all in a neat package and claim to save you up to 25% over individual piece purchasing. I know many friends that have Jasper engines, some in truck, others in race cars, and they have a solid nationwide reputation. They also go into great detail of the difference between remanufactured and rebuilt.

Also, it appears that Promar Engines on ebay has a good reputation, and reasonable pricing. Go to ebay, put this number in the search box, and hit enter. It should pull up a remanufactured 460 Long Block engine that would fit your needs. 290013997455

Oh yeah, keep the 460, the I-6 is a great torque monster when coupled with the proper rear end, but you ain't going to get to top speed, whether 60 or 90, very quick.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
RoperChick
Reg. Dec 2005
Posted 2006-12-28 12:23 AM (#52948 - in reply to #52818)
Subject: RE: Question for Gear Heads



Veteran


Posts: 238
10010025
Location: West Coast

I'd go with a remanufactured engine in your old truck.  Your F250 is a heavier duty truck, you've already rebuilt many of the parts in it and you are less likely to rip the guts out of it towing.  Plus the fuel mileage between the two will be pretty close to the same.

Edited to add:  We had a 3/4 ton with the 460, it was a much better truck to tow with than the 1/2 ton with the straight 6.  There was a *huge* difference between the two, I'd never want to go back to the 1/2 ton.



Edited by RoperChick 2006-12-28 12:12 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page