I think it's time we start looking out for us.
HWBar
Reg. Nov 2005
Posted 2008-11-27 5:19 AM (#95421)
Subject: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1283
1000100100252525
Location: Home of Wild Turkey Whiskey

Reading through the Sundowner thread and Gabz talks about buying American dirt, I wonder if the current economy has started anyone to thinking about buying American whenever possible. I have been doing it forever, I realize that with some items is hard to purchase made in America items, but do you even look to see if their is an option for you? In tough economic times the best thing we can do is spend our money here at home, it is those companies that are the employers that are creating the jobs here. Here are a couple of sites that I use to help me with purchasing decisions.

http://www.madeinusa.org/nav.cgi

http://www.madeinusa.com/



Edited by HWBar 2008-11-27 5:20 AM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-11-27 9:56 AM (#95432 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI

   I have the most difficult time trying to buy DECENT tools and equipment. I can't find US made much of anything. I don't care if the item cost more. I'm so sick of the crappy junk in the stores, yet I want to support local trades... 

So.. what I do is write as frequently as I can to my congress people. I tell them how unhappy I am about the lack of US made products. I tell them that anytime a trade agreement comes before them, to PLEASE consider what they are doing. The US has SO become a service supplier. It's sickening. That's why aerospace, ship building, & automotive manufacturing are so critical to our longevity. Even appliances are mfg overseas.!! 

  I avoid shopping at internet catalogs (and WalMart) that only offer chinese manufactured items. I'm so sick of JUNK. If a catalog offers REALLY cheap stuff... guess where it comes from? Those water buckets, lead ropes, halters, etc. etc. 

The Horse World is one of the few suppliers of tangible US Made items. Trucks to haul trailers that are built in the US. Horses grown and trained (service) in the US. Fencing, farm equipment, feed, etc.  - speaking of feed...

I'm sure some of you know this, but the reason we suffer shortages of some feed products - for instance, this year, it's beet pulp - is because the US Gov't has made commitments to EXPORT IT which means that if there is a bad harvest in a given year, there is LESS for US customers to buy. Yup.  Same with corn, oats, wheat, etc.  SUCKS BIG TIME.  So... let your government KNOW that it sucks.

While many of you are off work over the holidays, perhaps you can google on your state government websites and discover the email and snail mail addresses of your local and federal government representatives. Make a collection of their emails... and be prepared to CHANGE those email addresses after the newly elected reps go into office next year.

There are states that continually flux between identifying horses as livestock and pets. They MUST MUST MUST remain as livestock - otherwise, they will have absolutely ZERO VALUE - just like an abandoned dog or cat - something we are so close to right now, it's scary. All of us MUST make our voices heard against those who will take away this "made in America" product.

If someone in Europe or Japan wants to eat horsemeat. YEAH. Let's EXPORT some of the horses that can't be supported in the suburban OR wild areas of the country. Stop taking away a source of income. But by all means, let's find a way to process this product locally and put in methods to regulate it.  Hellp - let's just set up an entire Marketing Paradigm around corraling and exporting horses.

Phew. sorry.  Where's that Political Gab forum Dave was gonna give us?     (now you know why my username is gabz... ha ha ha)

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
rose
Reg. Feb 2004
Posted 2008-11-27 9:38 PM (#95440 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.




10005001002525
Location: KY

I do look at the tags to see where an item was made.  Recently I have tried to put down items made out side the US unless it was something I really really needed and could not find a US made item.  At least as far as food is concerned, I do buy locally whenever possible and at local farms. 

 

 Gabz   Me too.  I have been watching for the politics forum....would like to see it here.....when you get a chance Dave.    ps I love the Robert Duval photos



Edited by rose 2008-11-27 9:40 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Snickers
Reg. Nov 2004
Posted 2008-11-28 10:54 AM (#95445 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Veteran


Posts: 105
100
Location: Illinois

Yep, I also try to buy US products. Did go into one of the links you posted. Saw Justin boots listed BUT NOT ALL Justin boots are made in the US. Looked at a pair this Spring but put them back when I saw that they were made in China. Sent an E-mail to Justin told them that I had purchased Justin boots since the mid 60's  but that I would no longer do so. Know that they must run the business so they do make a profit but still I have a real hard time buying Chinese.

Later, found out that they still make boots in the US as well as China so I may rethink my position. Check out the Justin web site. 

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
KCW
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2008-11-28 1:20 PM (#95448 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Veteran


Posts: 252
1001002525
Location: Hunting Valley, Ohio


It's up to us to start dealing in our own national self interest.

If America could rebuild Western Europe after World War II, we ought to be able to rebuild our own country today.

Unless we act fast, our industrial heartland is going to turn into an industrial wasteland. Bail-out the Big 3, you bet, these are the people that made it possible for us to win WWII. Our industrial base is very important to the country. 

Is it too late for America? I don't know. I hope not.

KCW
  kcwalker@mail.com
We can not compete against low wage goods, if they can live on 3 pieces of rice and a nickel a day that's OK, but we can't do that and survive in America.
Free trade my A _ _ , We need to Level the Playing Field!


 



Edited by KCW 2008-12-01 12:12 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hogtownboss
Reg. Sep 2008
Posted 2008-11-28 9:20 PM (#95454 - in reply to #95448)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 1351
10001001001002525
Location: Decatur, Texas
Sure lets bail out the big 3 too! Lets not make them lower their profit margin... Just like the oil companies talking about record profits back in the summer, but still raised the price at the pump. Make sence to me, help the ones that are already make big money.4
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
ponytammy
Reg. Jan 2005
Posted 2008-11-29 8:15 AM (#95462 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Elite Veteran


Posts: 781
500100100252525
Location: La Cygne, KS

Have any of you noticed how many foreign food items are appearing on our grocery store shelves. Just go out and try to buy american grown pineapple in cans. I cannot locate one. Dole is canning from the phillipines and most apple juice is coming from CHINA!!! Next time you buy that jug of orange juice, look to see where it is made... most likely from some far off south american country. When was the last time you heard the Jingle "C&H sugar from Hawaii"? Well you won't, it's not made here anylonger.

I have even noticed the regular ground beef packages now state a product of Mexico/Canada/USA. Hellooo!!! I live in the heartland where steers/cows out number people. Why do we need Mexican or Candanian beef??? I told the meat market manager that I will no longer be buying any meat from his store. Went and bought from my local meat processor. Yes it cost more, but I know the meat was locally raised and butchered.

It is an awful shame that in this country of bountiful food that we cannot get american made food products on our shelves.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
jcross
Reg. Sep 2007
Posted 2008-11-29 11:18 AM (#95464 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Member


Posts: 26
25
Location: Kingsland, TX

I know we ty to buy US made products as often as possible.

My wife makes cowhide/leather bedspreads, purses and home accessories by hand, by herself. She gets copied and people buy the foreign "knockoffs" all day long. Cheaper price, cheaper quality and somewhat the same look. Its tough.

On the beef side, my inlaws are partners in a cattle sale barn and ranch full time. Lets just say that we don't buy our meat from any grocery store chain. We fully support the "mom and pop" shops. The meat prices when we buy a "loin" (about 80lbs-90lbs) are around $2.90lb and the meat is sooooo much better.

Just my two cents......

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Frankie001%
Reg. Feb 2005
Posted 2008-11-29 10:18 PM (#95483 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Veteran


Posts: 219
100100
Location: Mt. Clemens, MI 48043
WOW!  I thought I was the only one thinking like that.  I live in MI and people that I work with just want the cheapest food they can get.  I am always letting them know that if they don't buy from the American Farmers what are they really getting?  Other counties don't care if I go hungry as long as they get our money.  Farmer markets have provided me with so much I can not express my "Thanks."  From receipes to extra food to feed all the family and the flowers are wonderful.  They fill each room every year.  I do buy from the stores.  Lots of people would not even think of trying a co-op or working for food.  We have become just plane lazy and the attitudes are terrible.  It has gotten to the point I don't even talk about what I do since it is like beating a dead horse.  By the way I just found a new item that I'm going to use on my BBQ grill.  The item makes you able to prepare pancakes, eggs, omelets and bacon and other food.  It is from Sterling Heights, MI.  It is a little pricey but it should last as long as the BBQ.  Thanks for the websites.        
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Terri
Reg. Jan 2004
Posted 2008-11-29 10:42 PM (#95484 - in reply to #95483)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 2828
200050010010010025
Location: Southern New Mexico

I just found a new item that I'm going to use on my BBQ grill.  The item makes you able to prepare pancakes, eggs, omelets and bacon and other food.  It is from Sterling Heights, MI.  It is a little pricey but it should last as long as the BBQ.  Thanks for the websites.        

 

Well don't tell us about it with out telling us what it is!!!!!

I work part time at a retail store and I stopped looking at where stuff was made.  It was so depressing. 

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Spooler
Reg. Aug 2006
Posted 2008-11-30 2:50 AM (#95487 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Extreme Veteran


Posts: 544
50025
Location: Claxton, Ga.
I just bought new front wheel bearings for my older car.  The guy naturally assumed I wanted the cheap 3.00 bearings which were made in China.  I told him to give me the good bearings that will last.  Price difference was big.  15-16 dollars for the good ones. One day big business will figure out we will proudly pay more for quality stuff made in America. Some of the things made overseas is flat out junk.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-11-30 9:08 AM (#95493 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI

Peach trees originated in China... but believe it or not, it's cheaper for the companies to buy & process peaches, etc. in China and Thailand and then ship them to the US. How can that be?

That's because of labor costs. 

95% of garlic is from China. I wouldn't mind except I worry about the melamine additives that seem to be pervasive in their food manufacturing plants.

I broke another cheap (made in China) kitchen utensil the other day. grrrrr

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
crowleysridgegirl
Reg. Apr 2005
Posted 2008-11-30 7:40 PM (#95517 - in reply to #95462)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 2614
2000500100
Originally written by ponytammy on 2008-11-29 8:15 AM

Have any of you noticed how many foreign food items are appearing on our grocery store shelves. Just go out and try to buy american grown pineapple in cans. I cannot locate one. Dole is canning from the phillipines and most apple juice is coming from CHINA!!! Next time you buy that jug of orange juice, look to see where it is made... most likely from some far off south american country. When was the last time you heard the Jingle "C&H sugar from Hawaii"? Well you won't, it's not made here anylonger.

I have even noticed the regular ground beef packages now state a product of Mexico/Canada/USA. Hellooo!!! I live in the heartland where steers/cows out number people. Why do we need Mexican or Candanian beef??? I told the meat market manager that I will no longer be buying any meat from his store. Went and bought from my local meat processor. Yes it cost more, but I know the meat was locally raised and butchered.

It is an awful shame that in this country of bountiful food that we cannot get american made food products on our shelves.

Know that feeling.A few years ago,they were IMPORTING rice (mostly exotic varieties,but,still!) into a country where American rice farmers were going out of business and unable to give their crops away.Same for soybeans.(!!) Hundreds of soy based products with soy from Brazil crops.Jeeze.Thanks a lot.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
loveduffy
Reg. Feb 2006
Posted 2008-11-30 9:39 PM (#95523 - in reply to #95517)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1871
10005001001001002525
Location: NY

all the imports are because of the trade agreements they send food stuff we send money, toy are the same thing some toy have lead in them from china, candy imported also. we have become a country of importer, some body told e that cartoon are also imported WOW I got my turkey from a local farmer support your state and local farmer now 

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
hogtownboss
Reg. Sep 2008
Posted 2008-11-30 10:23 PM (#95527 - in reply to #95523)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 1351
10001001001002525
Location: Decatur, Texas
What about the tv, stereo and other items in your LQ trailer that is imported or made in china or other overseas places?

I looked at my fancy flipdown flat screen tv and my Jensen stereo system and both are made elsewhere!
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Frankie001%
Reg. Feb 2005
Posted 2008-12-01 6:30 AM (#95532 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Veteran


Posts: 219
100100
Location: Mt. Clemens, MI 48043
Sorry it is called Quiddle Q - it is like a open flat grill that restaurants use but you use it over your BBQ grill and is smaller.  It is made in the good old USA. 
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmbabe
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 3:00 PM (#95542 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 1723
1000500100100
Location: michigan
I hate to burst your bubble here folks. The best thing for the ecomony and consumers is free trade which means I want to be able to choose from a variety of goods at a price I am willing to pay no matter where they are made. My car is a Kia which is 99% made in korea however amercian workers are needed to transport,market and repair this vechile which is a good thing for those workers. They have a job, I have a car- everyone is happy. Competetion in the market place assures the consumers of high quality,large selection and lower prices- this is good for all of us. if you want to buy only amercian made products, fine you can do that with free trade. If you want to buy what suits your needs and at a price your willing to pay, you will not get that without free trade.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 3:43 PM (#95544 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI

While free trade is necessary... I don't SEE anything other then foreign made tools and kitchen utensils in local stores.

So far as your vehicle made in another country. The labor costs that you mentioned are low-income jobs - not middle class. Additionally, the engineering and testing of the vehicle paid employees in another country. The parts will STILL come from a foreign country and the profits will return to that foreign country.

I'm not for blocking imports. I am against the crap that we DO import. Part of is is because the American public wants to spend as little as possible; however, when I go into a store and can find ONLY Imported TVs, or ONLY imported tools, when my groceries are imported when the very same commodity is grown and produced here, then I get fed up. That's due to the government ALLOWING that to happen.

When I can't buy beet pulp because it's being EXPORTED so that we can import more junk toys and more junk tools, and even foreign DESIGNED and MANUFACTURED vehicles, then I get fed up.  And, when Chinese investors own 51% of previously US companies... then I get sick.



Edited by gabz 2008-12-02 5:09 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmbabe
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 3:49 PM (#95545 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 1723
1000500100100
Location: michigan

So what if that money goes back to Korea? You do think it stays there? Of course not, when people in Korea make money, they buy other stuff they cannot grow or make themselves. They might buy somthing from THIS country which employs people which in turn allows people in this country the ability to buy stuff they want to buy.

 

The problem is the basic ignorance of ecomonics. Its never taught properly in schools and the assumptions being made here by Gabz is reenforced by polticans and the media who are also equally ignorant. Its a shame really.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmbabe
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 3:56 PM (#95546 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 1723
1000500100100
Location: michigan

Here is some good reading to help those who just cannot understand ecomonics

A MINORITY VIEW

BY WALTER E. WILLIAMS

RELEASE: WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 26, 2008, AND THEREAFTER

 

Trade versus Protectionism

 

            There's a growing anti-trade sentiment in our country. Much of the dialogue is grossly misinformed. Let's try to untangle it a bit with a few questions and observations. First, does the U.S. trade with Japan and England? Put another way, is it members of the U.S. Congress trading with their counterparts in the Japanese Diet or the English Parliament? An affirmative answer is pure nonsense. When I purchased my Lexus, I had nothing to do with either the Japanese Diet or the U.S. Congress. Through an intermediary, a Lexus dealer, I dealt with Toyota Motor Corporation.

            While it might be convenient to speak of one country trading with another, such aggregation can conceal a lot of evil, particularly when people call for trade barriers. For example, what would be a moral case for third-party interference, by either the Japanese Diet or the U.S. Congress, with an exchange between me and Toyota Motor Corporation? Some might reason that since Japan places restrictions on U.S. products entering their country, an appropriate retaliatory measure is not to allow Japanese products to freely enter the U.S. By the way, Japanese protectionist restrictions on rice imports force Japanese consumers to pay three or four times the world price for rice. How much sense does it make for Congress to retaliate against Japan by imposing restrictions on their products thereby forcing American consumers, say Lexus buyers, to pay higher prices? Should our rule be: If one country screws its citizens we should retaliate by screwing our citizens?

            Since there is no moral argument for preventing one person from trading with another, anti-traders shift their argument to a patriotic appeal such as suggesting that we're losing our manufacturing sector. That doesn't square with the facts. According to a report given by Dr. William Strauss, senior economist for the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, titled "Is U.S. Losing Its Manufacturing Base?" (http://www.edcchicago.org/ecom/2008/edc062508.htm) the answer is no. In each of the past 60 years, U.S. manufacturing output growth has averaged 4 percent and productivity growth has averaged 3 percent. Manufacturing is going through the same process as agriculture. In 1900, 41 percent of American workers were employed in agriculture; today, only 2 percent are and agricultural output is greater. In 1940, 35 percent of workers were employed in manufacturing jobs; today, it's about 10 percent. Again, because of huge productivity gains, manufacturing output is greater.

            The decline in manufacturing employment is not limited to the U.S. Since 2000, China has lost over 4.5 million manufacturing jobs. In fact, nine of the top 10 manufacturing countries, which produce 75 percent of the world's manufacturing output (the U.S., Japan, Germany, China, Britain, France, Italy, Korea, Canada, and Mexico), have lost manufacturing jobs but their manufacturing output has risen.

            Despite the pretense of being a free trade nation, the U.S. has significant barriers to trade that come in the form of tariffs, quotas and steep regulatory barriers. Our restrictions are just not as onerous as many other countries but there's a push to make them so. It's simple politics. The people who face foreign competition, say management and workers in the auto industry, are well organized, have narrowly shared interests and the resources to have considerable clout in Washington to get Congress to enact trade barriers. Restricting foreign competition means higher prices for their products, and hence higher profits and fuller employment in their industry. The people who are benefited by foreign competition, say auto consumers, have widely dispersed interests; they are not organized at all and have little clout in Washington. You never see consumers descending on Washington complaining about cheap prices for foreign products; it's always domestic producers who do the complaining.

            The relationship between prosperity and economic freedom, including free trade, is a no-brainer. But if you need hard evidence, check out the Heritage Foundation's "Index of Economic Freedom" (http://www.heritage.org/Index). You'll find that nations having the greatest measure of economic freedom are the most prosperous and peaceful.

Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason University. To find out more about Walter E. Williams and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
loveduffy
Reg. Feb 2006
Posted 2008-12-01 4:03 PM (#95548 - in reply to #95546)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1871
10005001001001002525
Location: NY
farmbabe you are right  about free trade ,I am just tired of seeing job go over to other country were works are pay a lot less and the stuff is not made well at all
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 4:31 PM (#95551 - in reply to #95545)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI
Originally written by farmbabe on 2008-12-01 4:49 PM

So what if that money goes back to Korea? You do think it stays there? Of course not, when people in Korea make money, they buy other stuff they cannot grow or make themselves. They might buy somthing from THIS country which employs people which in turn allows people in this country the ability to buy stuff they want to buy.

The problem is the basic ignorance of ecomonics. Its never taught properly in schools and the assumptions being made here by Gabz is reenforced by polticans and the media who are also equally ignorant. Its a shame really.

Since the US hardly manufactures anything anymore, pray tell, what do the people in Korea buy from us? Rice? Beet Pulp? Do they buy trailers or farm tractors? no. Do they buy shoes, shampoo, toothpaste, or clothing from the US? no.  Do they buy raw materials from the US? perhaps, but probably not much and raw materials are certainly not consumer items.

The "people" of Korea don't buy much of anything. The large commercial enterprises buy technology and then build the manufacturing infrastructure themselves.  (Simplified version)

I understand about free trade; however, in order to keep exports/imports in balance and since US-manufactured goods are typically more expensive, we have to import MORE junk to equal the high-tech / service dollars being exported.

Economics. My background is a little old since I went to college back in the late 1980s when I was "older". In fact, it was after I had worked in various retail establishments for many years; after I had been in the Army and employed by the Department of Defense. (Back when I was entitled to full GI bill college benefits for having served my country only to have Congress slash my benefits in order to support some other out-of-country contrivance.)

As stated previously, we helped the Germans and Japan to rebuild after global wars. We showed them how to become manufacturers of real goods. Now we will help China to become a manufacturing giant and people can flock to Walmart and buy the goods that they SHOULD have been employed making.

It's a complex system .... and since the world decided to base it's economy on the US Dollar instead of gold - it's gotten even more complex.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
headhunter
Reg. Oct 2004
Posted 2008-12-01 4:46 PM (#95552 - in reply to #95548)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Elite Veteran


Posts: 736
50010010025
Location: Western WA

I believe quality in manufacturing is a problem across the board!  If you want high-end kitchen utensils, shop at a high-end kitchen store. 

I don't think US-made goods are of a higher quality across the board.  I drive a Japanese car and tow my horse trailer with a US-made truck, but only because Nissan, Honda, or Toyota do not make a one ton.   I'd go out and buy a Japanese-built one ton in a heartbeat if they become available. 

We have a global economy whether we like it or not.  The catalyst of change will be our quality and efficiency of manufacturing at home.   I'm sure this will cause me to be flamed, but costs would decrease and quality would increase if the manufacturing unions could be reined in.   I'm tired of the sense of entitlement the unions seem to have.  Unions are completely out of touch with patriotism and doing what is right for the country.  They are only looking out for themselves and look where it has gotten us as a country. 

Case in point:  I live in the Seattle area, and one of the Boeing unions went on strike recently, holding out for wage, health insurance, and retirement benefit INCREASES.  A second union thought they would follow suit but came to a contract agreement prior to striking.   Really, is this the time to hold a manufacturing company, their clients, and all their subcontractors and suppliers hostage because of the bully power of your union?  I think not.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 4:54 PM (#95554 - in reply to #95546)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI

HOLY CRAP...  NO wonder it's a minority view...  my comments in RED...

Originally written by farmbabe on 2008-12-01 4:56 PM

Here is some good reading to help those who just cannot understand ecomonics

A MINORITY VIEW

BY WALTER E. WILLIAMS

RELEASE: WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 26, 2008, AND THEREAFTER

 

Trade versus Protectionism

There's a growing anti-trade sentiment in our country. Much of the dialogue is grossly misinformed. Let's try to untangle it a bit with a few questions and observations. First, does the U.S. trade with Japan and England? Put another way, is it members of the U.S. Congress trading with their counterparts in the Japanese Diet or the English Parliament? An affirmative answer is pure nonsense. When I purchased my Lexus, I had nothing to do with either the Japanese Diet or the U.S. Congress. Through an intermediary, a Lexus dealer, I dealt with Toyota Motor Corporation.

            While it might be convenient to speak of one country trading with another, such aggregation can conceal a lot of evil, particularly when people call for trade barriers. For example, what would be a moral case for third-party interference, by either the Japanese Diet or the U.S. Congress, with an exchange between me and Toyota Motor Corporation? Some might reason that since Japan places restrictions on U.S. products entering their country, an appropriate retaliatory measure is not to allow Japanese products to freely enter the U.S. By the way, Japanese protectionist restrictions on rice imports force Japanese consumers to pay three or four times the world price for rice. How much sense does it make for Congress to retaliate against Japan by imposing restrictions on their products thereby forcing American consumers, say Lexus buyers, to pay higher prices? Why not? Other countries do this to US Made products (not just cars).  Should our rule be: If one country screws its citizens we should retaliate by screwing our citizens?

Not in the absolute sense. However, the US government has agreed to sell XX amount of certain commodities to foreign countries. Now with a shortage of those commodities, the US consumer must pay a much higher price due to the shortage. Oh, and gee. that means we can't spend as much money on foreign made junk. (I don't mean automobiles, heavy equipment, aircraft, ships, etc. I mean the under $2000 junk.

            Since there is no moral argument for preventing one person from trading with another, anti-traders shift their argument to a patriotic appeal such as suggesting that we're losing our manufacturing sector. That doesn't square with the facts. According to a report given by Dr. William Strauss, senior economist for the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, titled "Is U.S. Losing Its Manufacturing Base?" (http://www.edcchicago.org/ecom/2008/edc062508.htm) the answer is no. In each of the past 60 years, U.S. manufacturing output growth has averaged 4 percent and productivity growth has averaged 3 percent. Manufacturing is going through the same process as agriculture. In 1900, 41 percent of American workers were employed in agriculture; today, only 2 percent are and agricultural output is greater.   We might be producing MORE but fewer individuals are employed. When fewer individuals are employed, you lose your tax base so far as personal income tax; you also lose paychecks in the hands of consumers. Larger corporations are producing agricultural goods yet it's still economically profitable to IMPORT many foodstuffs from foreign countries.  In 1940, 35 percent of workers were employed in manufacturing jobs; today, it's about 10 percent. Again, because of huge productivity gains, manufacturing output is greater.   Mfg output may be GREATER - but there are FEWER people (i.e., CONSUMERS) employed. 35 percent versus less than 10 percent of the population. If fewer people are employed, who will buy the goods? Who will pay personal income tax to the government to support it?

            The decline in manufacturing employment is not limited to the U.S. Since 2000, China has lost over 4.5 million manufacturing jobs. In fact, nine of the top 10 manufacturing countries, which produce 75 percent of the world's manufacturing output (the U.S., Japan, Germany, China, Britain, France, Italy, Korea, Canada, and Mexico), have lost manufacturing jobs but their manufacturing output has risen.

            Despite the pretense of being a free trade nation, the U.S. has significant barriers to trade that come in the form of tariffs, quotas and steep regulatory barriers. Our restrictions are just not as onerous as many other countries but there's a push to make them so. It's simple politics. The people who face foreign competition, say management and workers in the auto industry, are well organized, have narrowly shared interests and the resources to have considerable clout in Washington to get Congress to enact trade barriers. Restricting foreign competition means higher prices for their products, and hence higher profits and fuller employment in their industry. The people who are benefited by foreign competition, say auto consumers, have widely dispersed interests; they are not organized at all and have little clout in Washington. You never see consumers descending on Washington complaining about cheap prices for foreign products; it's always domestic producers who do the complaining. No. We don't complain about cheap PRICES, but we DO complain about CHEAP products. Unfortunately, the majority of people complain about cheaply made products to each other and NOT to the government.  We wait until children die from CHEAPLY MADE products. We wait until people are INJURED. Then we wail and gnash out teeth and expect the GOVERNMENT to help. Then we COMPLAIN because the government costs too much.             The relationship between prosperity and economic freedom, including free trade, is a no-brainer. But if you need hard evidence, check out the Heritage Foundation's "Index of Economic Freedom" (http://www.heritage.org/Index). You'll find that nations having the greatest measure of economic freedom are the most prosperous and peaceful.

Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason University. To find out more about Walter E. Williams and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at www.creators.com.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 4:58 PM (#95555 - in reply to #95532)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI

Originally written by Frankie001% on 2008-12-01 7:30 AM

Sorry it is called Quiddle Q - it is like a open flat grill that restaurants use but you use it over your BBQ grill and is smaller.  It is made in the good old USA. 

Okay. I googled for this device and nothing came up other than games.

Is there a website that demonstrates this item? How can someone purchase this item if they wanted to? 

 

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 5:24 PM (#95557 - in reply to #95552)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI
Originally written by headhunter on 2008-12-01 5:46 PM

I believe quality in manufacturing is a problem across the board!  If you want high-end kitchen utensils, shop at a high-end kitchen store. 

 I don't think US-made goods are of a higher quality across the board. 

I agree somewhat. I do shop at high-end stores when I can. However, I posted that I was concerned about the lack of choice in LOCAL STORES where I try to shop.  

 I drive a Japanese car and tow my horse trailer with a US-made truck, but only because Nissan, Honda, or Toyota do not make a one ton.   I'd go out and buy a Japanese-built one ton in a heartbeat if they become available.

Why is that? Because they are cheaper? or because they have features and benefits that US-made trucks do not have? 

I had this conversation with my boss this morning. It's not just about buying US to save a job or being patriotic. It's about buying what vehicle has the features and benefits at the $$ I am willing to pay.  Again, it's about having a choice of well-made goods.

We have a global economy whether we like it or not.  The catalyst of change will be our quality and efficiency of manufacturing at home.   I'm sure this will cause me to be flamed, but costs would decrease and quality would increase if the manufacturing unions could be reined in.   I'm tired of the sense of entitlement the unions seem to have.  Unions are completely out of touch with patriotism and doing what is right for the country.  They are only looking out for themselves and look where it has gotten us as a country. 

No kidding. I agree. I'm NOT a pro-union person. I believe that increases should be based on responsibility and expertise. This "across the board" increase in pay and benefits - regardless of tenure - has always left me shaking my head in dismay.  However, there has been a shift in the automotive unions in the past few years (not soon enough) to have "step" pay and benefits (FINALLY) based on years of experience.

Case in point:  I live in the Seattle area, and one of the Boeing unions went on strike recently, holding out for wage, health insurance, and retirement benefit INCREASES.  A second union thought they would follow suit but came to a contract agreement prior to striking.   Really, is this the time to hold a manufacturing company, their clients, and all their subcontractors and suppliers hostage because of the bully power of your union?  I think not.

Again, I agree.  I am NOT pro-union, pro-US Made to the blind sight of anything else. I am only encouraging folks to take an active role in what their concerns are. I hear too much grumbling amongst ourselves and not enough people who are willing to take the time to find out WHO their government representatives are and where to write to them.

And... at this point in time, in the US. we've made our bed. If we let too much of it to fall, it will have a greater impact then we may be able to dig ourselves out of.   SO far as the "Big 3" "bailout".  First, it should only be for Ford and GM... since Chrysler is a privately owned company once Daimler bailed out. 

next, it's not about handing over 25 million dollars. It's about loans, with interest to be paid back. and YES, YES, YES, they MUST present a plan. 

Since you live in the PNW - If you can imagine what it would be like if the 10s of thousands of Boeing employees suddenly being out of work if the plants closed because neither US or other countries were buying aircraft because there was no credit. Houses foreclosed and simply abandoned!!; loss of property tax in the school districts and local government - yet the same amount of roads, etc. to maintain. Loss of consumers for local services and products. loss of corporate property tax and corporate support in the community.  Once houses are foreclosed or sold below loan value, then everyone else's homes become devalued. Then, if the people who hold houses that are "upside-down" in credit WANT to move, they cannot find a buyer since so many houses are for sale through foreclosure. If they sell, it's less than what the mortgage is for which means they have to come up with $20,000, $40,000, even $100,000 to pay the bank/ mortgage company to get out of the home. Now, these same people can find work elsewhere but have zero dollars for a down payment.

It's really a wicked cycle.

yup. it is.

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
headhunter
Reg. Oct 2004
Posted 2008-12-01 5:43 PM (#95559 - in reply to #95557)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Elite Veteran


Posts: 736
50010010025
Location: Western WA
Originally written by gabz on 2008-12-01 3:24 PM

Originally written by headhunter on 2008-12-01 5:46 PM

   I drive a Japanese car and tow my horse trailer with a US-made truck, but only because Nissan, Honda, or Toyota do not make a one ton.   I'd go out and buy a Japanese-built one ton in a heartbeat if they become available.

Why is that? Because they are cheaper? or because they have features and benefits that US-made trucks do not have? 

Reliability!  IMHO the Japanese build a better made automobile than the US.  Take a quick peek through Consumer Reports and look at the overall rating of anything Japanese vs anything American.

 

 



Edited by headhunter 2008-12-01 5:49 PM
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
gabz
Reg. Oct 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 6:31 PM (#95562 - in reply to #95559)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1391
1000100100100252525
Location: North of Detroit, MI

Yup. for the most part I agree. I owned 3 VWs; 3 Datsuns (Nisson now); then a European-built Ford. When I moved to the Detroit area, I started buying Ford because I could get a huge discount through a relative. I can get steep discounts on any of the Big 3... but I stick with Ford. I do own a subcompact Chevy though.

So for me, they are cheap enough to dispose of every 2 or 3 years LOL... before the ashtray gets full!! ha ha ha... very old joke.  

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
HWBar
Reg. Nov 2005
Posted 2008-12-01 6:47 PM (#95564 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



Expert


Posts: 1283
1000100100252525
Location: Home of Wild Turkey Whiskey
While I agree with the premise of free trade, (you need my stuff I need your stuff) I also agree that it will eventually settle to the lowest common denominator. For example if Koreas auto workers will work for $10 per hour so that a car can be sold for $12,000 then sooner or later all auto workers around the globe will have to be at those labor rates to compete. Sure you can sell a better product for more money, but you have to be "in the ballpark". So i think that we have sold out our higher paying jobs just to see a little relief when purchasing our "fruit of the looms". That wasn't so smart in my opinion.
share Top of the page Bottom of the page
farmbabe
Reg. Nov 2003
Posted 2008-12-01 7:00 PM (#95565 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Expert


Posts: 1723
1000500100100
Location: michigan

* sigh* if you have been working for the government then of course you don't understand ecomonics............

 

anyway- buy whatever you want..thats the great thing about free trade- allow the market place to determine what should sell and what shouldn't......

share Top of the page Bottom of the page
Frankie001%
Reg. Feb 2005
Posted 2008-12-02 7:40 AM (#95586 - in reply to #95421)
Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


Veteran


Posts: 219
100100
Location: Mt. Clemens, MI 48043
I must have spelled it wrong.  It is Griddle Q and the website is: 
  • www.griddleq.com    Sorry for the mistake. 
  • share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    gabz
    Reg. Oct 2003
    Posted 2008-12-02 8:19 AM (#95589 - in reply to #95565)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1391
    1000100100100252525
    Location: North of Detroit, MI
    Originally written by farmbabe on 2008-12-01 8:00 PM

    * sigh* if you have been working for the government then of course you don't understand ecomonics............

     

    I beg your pardon? Did you miss a smiley face or LOL?  I certainly hope that was an attempt at humor.

    Did you ever promise to lay down your life for the good of your country? 

    After I was honorably discharged with, among other things, a Commendation Medal, I worked for the DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE. With Military People - those underpaid folks who frequently have to sign up for Food stamps and other aid.

    Get Off it. Just because someone works for the government doesn't make them blind to a side of an argument. I'm voicing MY opinion, my freedom of speech. YOU are making this personal.

    P.S.  I haven't held a "government" job for more than 20 years. 



    Edited by gabz 2008-12-03 11:29 AM
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    loveduffy
    Reg. Feb 2006
    Posted 2008-12-03 9:24 AM (#95656 - in reply to #95589)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1871
    10005001001001002525
    Location: NY
    free trade is part of this country's history, i do not agree with all these bale outs. if i or you make a bad investment then we have to work with it. should the tax payers pay for these?
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    Frankie001%
    Reg. Feb 2005
    Posted 2008-12-03 11:35 AM (#95666 - in reply to #95421)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


    Veteran


    Posts: 219
    100100
    Location: Mt. Clemens, MI 48043
    I want a bail out too.  Don't need as much as the other companies need.  I am the president, share holder (60%), and part of the working crew.  How much can I get? 
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    loveduffy
    Reg. Feb 2006
    Posted 2008-12-04 7:38 PM (#95748 - in reply to #95666)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1871
    10005001001001002525
    Location: NY
    because of the economy some horse haulers are not doing as much businesses as before, less people are going to Florida should they get a bail out ??
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    PaulChristenson
    Reg. Jan 2007
    Posted 2008-12-04 11:21 PM (#95767 - in reply to #95666)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


    Expert


    Posts: 3853
    200010005001001001002525
    Location: Vermont

    Originally written by Frankie001% on 2008-12-03 12:35 PM

    I want a bail out too.  Don't need as much as the other companies need.  I am the president, share holder (60%), and part of the working crew.  How much can I get? 

    Well if your going out of business affected as many people as will be affected by GM and/or Chrysler going into Chapter 11...then I would say you need a bailout...it is all a matter of scale...

    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    HWBar
    Reg. Nov 2005
    Posted 2008-12-05 5:54 AM (#95772 - in reply to #95421)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1283
    1000100100252525
    Location: Home of Wild Turkey Whiskey
    I disagree with the bailouts completely, if the big three truely can get back above board then they should go through bankruptcy. Someone will buy them if they really have any value to them, just as Warren Buffet bought JP Morgan. The problem with the big 3 is they have been regulated by the unions(higher wages and benefits) and the government(cafe' standards and EPA regulations) into the mess they are in, I blame the leadership for allowing this to happen. The same leadership that now says they can bring them out of this hole with a little government help. I have heard as much as 70% of the people are against such bailout but the boneheads we elect seem to think they are much smarter than us lower forms of life. So with all of the above being said, I bought 725 shares of GM stock a few weeks back at $2.70 a share, so go ahead and bail them out, so I can cash in. I'm not a big stock trader by no means but I was sure that the bonehead politicians were going to bailout the big three so I thought I would cash in on it. As of last night I had already made about $1,000, but if they get a bailout I expect that to go up 20 times over the next year. If you can't beat them, join them.......................
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    Gone
    Reg. May 2005
    Posted 2008-12-05 6:58 AM (#95774 - in reply to #95421)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


    Elite Veteran


    Posts: 1069
    10002525
    Location: MI.
    Anyone who receives money from the bailout should have to pay it back.....with interest.
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    Frankie001%
    Reg. Feb 2005
    Posted 2008-12-05 7:41 AM (#95781 - in reply to #95421)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.


    Veteran


    Posts: 219
    100100
    Location: Mt. Clemens, MI 48043
    Here is my two cents.  All of the car companies knew they had to change for quite a while.  But they didn't.  So other countries vehicles did what Ford, GM, Chysler could have done.  I don't agree with the "Buy Out."  I did not agree with the banks "Buy Out" either.  My economic teacher has always said to my class "What goes up-Must come down."  What happens when it goes down depends on the company and how they are willing to change or adapt.  History repeating itself again.           
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    gabz
    Reg. Oct 2003
    Posted 2008-12-05 8:51 AM (#95783 - in reply to #95421)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1391
    1000100100100252525
    Location: North of Detroit, MI

    Technically it's not a buy out or a bail out. It's making money available in loans.

    A different $25 billion in loans is through the Energy Department and was set aside so that the automakers could retool for more fuel efficient vehicles. However, if a company applies for those monies, they have to prove themselves credit-worthy - which is why GM is getting beat up so badly.

    While I'm not strongly for or against advancing the money to automakers, I AM quite perturbed that the FDIC handed over more than $700 BILLION dollars to financial institutions without all the questions and finger-pointing that automakers and UAW president are facing.

    I'm sorry I didn't catch every last detail, but as a for instance... Citigroup, after being bailed out, went ahead with a $400 or $500 million ad campaign which included either buying a sports/ball field or buying a sign for said sports/ball field. When questioned about it, Citigroup said that advertising was very important. What the fruitbat is THAT about? And, are the financial companies requiring their CEOs, presidents, CFOs, etc. to take $1 annual salaries? grrrrrr.

    I know right after AIG and other financials were "bailed" (given guarenteed loans), there was a multitude of news items about rip off situations in the companies being bailed. So it's not just auto makers that are not looking ahead. 

    I still say Chrysler needs to dealt with differently than Ford & GM since it's a privately held company and not publicly traded.

    If the credit market would stabilize and confidence would come back, then people can buy cars (and houses and horse trailers) and the automakers and other manufacturing can begin to stabilize. Heck. People were spending their grocery money on gas this past summer and had nothing to spend on anything else. And then for horse people, add in hay & feed at 2x the amount 2 years ago... it's a huge complex issue. 

    Ford was down 33% in sales and Toyota was down 31%. I didn't compare any others. But that shows you that it's not just US manufacturers that have lost sales and therefore, lost revenue to cover operating costs. I know that the trailer manufacturers and dealers are all feeling the same belt tightening. They are paying $$$ on warehouse, factories, property, employee taxes & wages, with nothing coming in.

    But... as the OP started this... watching out for our behinds... if that's protectionism... well maybe the US needs just a tiny bit more of it by way of keeping manufacturing in the US instead of importing products manufactured elsewhere. And to do that, it means employees have to accept less pay in return for steady income.  Mortgage holders will have to tighten their belts and accept lower interest and longer payback periods so that people don't lose their homes. Slash salaries there too.

     

    edited to correct where the money is from/for.



    Edited by gabz 2008-12-05 9:01 AM
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    loveduffy
    Reg. Feb 2006
    Posted 2008-12-05 11:51 AM (#95791 - in reply to #95783)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1871
    10005001001001002525
    Location: NY
    I just remember that this is the second time Chrysler  has been bailed out , is that right??  if this is the second time then they are not doing something  right as far as running a company right were is the money going ??
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    KCW
    Reg. Nov 2003
    Posted 2008-12-05 2:26 PM (#95801 - in reply to #95791)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Veteran


    Posts: 252
    1001002525
    Location: Hunting Valley, Ohio

    Do you remember Lee Iacocca???
    http://to-error-is-human.spaces.live.com/blog/cns!505020A0E7148925!2211.entry


    Quote: "A lot of Americans think if it's made in Japan, it's terrific, if it's made in America, it's lousy. It's time to peel off the Teflon kimono."

    Quote: We at Chrysler borrow money the old fashion way. We pay it back.

    — Lee Iacocca

     

     



    Edited by KCW 2008-12-05 2:41 PM
    share Top of the page Bottom of the page
    gabz
    Reg. Oct 2003
    Posted 2008-12-05 4:55 PM (#95815 - in reply to #95791)
    Subject: RE: I think it's time we start looking out for us.



    Expert


    Posts: 1391
    1000100100100252525
    Location: North of Detroit, MI

    Yes. Second time for Chrysler; however, Lee Iacocca DID make that company profitable...  he had to. He took little or no salary but DID take incentives... so he would only make any money if the company did.

    I remember "back then" when Detroit was failing like it is now... and then it was because of imports, because those were the only cars worth buying.  The automakers DID learn, but then...  the $$$ took over, once again.

    "back then (1979-1981 or so)... workers left Michigan for Texas. I was in Texas and headed TO Michigan.

     

    share Top of the page Bottom of the page